Skip to content

Photography Gear and Technique / Archived topic

Topside lens testing validity?

Started by imasleeper ·

  • 3Posts
  • 3Replies

Read-only discussion

Topside lens testing validity?

3 posts
  1. What does the validity of topside lens testing mean to underwater use? For instance, if you find by testing above water that a given 16mm to 35mm zoom wide angle lens has awesome performance by all the usual standards, does that automatically mean that it will perform equally well underwater? And if it doesn't is it simply do to a lens/port mismatch that can be corrected with enough experimenting with various configurations? Does the same hold true for macro lens? If possible, please constrain the discussion to lens that are optimal and typically used underwater, such as fisheye's, 10mm to 40mm, both primes and zooms, and 50,60,and 100mm macros. All opinions welcome!

     

    Thanks,

     

    imasleeper

  2. Very simply, the better the lens above water, the better its potential is below. This said when you use any lens behind a relatively thick sheet of flat glass, perspex, acrylic, etc, or behind a simple curved dome port (which is a lens in itself) these will degrade the resulting image. Degredation is worst at extremes (such as with wide angle with a greater than 90 degree field of view.

     

    I find that I carry out some degree of correction for chromatic problems (due to flat ports) on most macro shots these days (and careful scrutiny of film shots show that its always been there we just couldn't do anything about it) but the settings vary depending on lens and focused distance.

     

    Lens/port mismatches can occur as optical configurations change (due to zooming) so experimentation is sometimes useful to establish and optimum set up for a specific focal length. There has been a lot of discussion on this topic on wetpixel before.

  3. I find testing a lens top side is usefull for evaluating its quality level and my expectation, then I proceed to the pool and get on with the u/w testing to find the optimal positioning of the dome to optical axis of the lens, you can't expect miracle from lens with their ever shifting nodal point, but I always strive to get the wide part of it sharp as can be. having a top side reference helps me to see if i'm in the boonies or if its just a so, so lens.

     

    On the topic of macro port, some of the older generation photographer (The guys from the yellow cover magazine) where ordering their macro port with a dome lens, basically it was (still is available) a 6'' dome machined down to size and installed where the flat port sat. Since the return of full frame digital, I'm thinking this might be an elegant solution to some chromatic abberation. <_< look like I will have to take a 5D down and check if my big theory is right, this being said you get rid of that flat port refraction, you get rid of that extra magnification . Mmmm, which one is less painfull to loose :)

     

    will keep posted on result.

Keldan

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.