- 9Posts
- 9Replies
Read-only discussion
Is it real, or is it Photoshop?
-
-
I think i have seen this somewhere before .. as one of those famous real shots .. but i wait to be told i'm wrong.
it's like the one of the shark in the wave .. there are fakes but there is a real one too.
-
I guess the lack of wave action/any texture on the surface in the zone between the shark and the bottom of frame and to the bottom right of frame could be explained away by a wind-shadow from the boat the image was shot from...?
Whether it is real or a composite, I think the mere act of questioning an image's integrity tends to devalue that image in the eye of subsequent viewers.
darren
-
-
It is real. Taken by Tom Peshak - from his book on S Africa. Currents of Contrast.
Alex
-
cool.
-
How sad that everything is suspect. What an image!
Now look at the thread that John Bantin has been sustaining for the last few weeks....
Tim
B)
-
It's touched. Look at the dorsal fin shadow and the lack of shadow under the starboard paddle.
It is real. Taken by Tom Peshak - from his book on S Africa. Currents of Contrast.Alex
-
It's touched. Look at the dorsal fin shadow and the lack of shadow under the starboard paddle.
I think that the dorsal fin "shadow" is actually a reflection. Similarly the paddle has a white reflection that is more diffuse and separated since it is higher off of the waters. IMO.