Skip to content

Video Gear and Technique / Archived topic

1080i50 or 1080i60?

Started by Nick Hope ·

  • 10Posts
  • 10Replies

Read-only discussion

1080i50 or 1080i60?

10 posts
  1. Decisions, decisions... I'm really torn about whether to shoot 1080i50 or 1080i60 with my new Z1. The liveaboard souvenir DVDs are still an important consideration for me but these days I'm primarily thinking of optimising for stock footage sales and my own productions.

     

    Advantages of 50i

     

    - Better picture quality (using the space saved by temporal resolution)

    - Better transfer to film than 60i

    - Native framerate for the majority of my liveaboard customers (so their PAL SD DVDs, which they'll continue to get for the next year or two, will be sharper)

    - If transcoding is required, a 60fps encode from a 50i source is better than a 50fps encode from a 60i source (???)

     

    Advantages of 60i

     

    - Better temporal resolution (obviously) so better slo-mo etc.

    - In general more international stock footage purchasers would prefer 60i (???)

    - We're heading towards and era of 60p(?), so the footage will be more useable in the medium-longterm

    - I can make SD NTSC DVDs for my liveaboard customers and the vast majority will be able to play them on their multi-system TVs. No more making 9 x PAL DVDs and 1 x NTSC DVD for the American/Japanese guy.

    - Will convert more nicely to 15p which is perfect for web movies (conversely 12.5p half PAL is a little low)

     

    That's how I'm seeing things at the moment and I'm leaning towards 60i. Any opinions? Any things I haven't considered? Any corrections to the above? Which framerate would NGC/Discovery/BBC prefer (leaving aside the need to upconvert)?

    Edited by bubblevision
  2. Har Har , you finally got a HDV camera and now you don't know which to shoot in. PAL /NTSC ;)

     

    Well I'm on a 50i HDV camera but yet I still sold to the NTSC USA WORLD no problems.

     

    Then you will shoot in HDV NTSC but the UK company wants it in HDV PAL :)

    Seriously it's allot easy to convert HDV 50i to 60i and vise versa now days than DV PAL/NTSC.

     

    Look at Aspect HD, it can convert it as it comes in to the computer and it looks okay.

    Encoding out a 60i from a 50i timeline with Edius looks good as well.

  3. Ah you're just jealous Wags cuz yours only has 546 menu choices and not 832 ;) Yeah, maybe I'll bottle out and just shoot DV with it ... In fact I wonder if it does hi-8 :)

     

    Live transcoding on capture is something I'm hoping to avoid if possible. Native .m2t editing seems more than usable in Vegas 7 on my 3.0 GHz P4 and I don't do that many effects. The 2.0GHz laptop I take on the liveaboards doesn't really have the balls for smooth native .m2t editing so for I'm looking at the following workflow:

     

    1. Live down-convert to DV in the Z1 while capturing with Sclive

    2. Edit in DV on the laptop and do previews on TV just like before (but in NTSC if I go 60i)

    3. Recapture in HDV during breaks using HDVsplit

    3. Back at base knock out SD DVDs on my desktop PC from the completed SD DV timeline, same as before

    4. Switch the DV files on the timeline for the HDV ones using Gearshift (Vegas plug-in for using DV proxies)

    5. Archive the mating mantas and battling blue whales in glorious HDV

    6. Bin the DV files and the unused HDV files

     

    I'm looking at Connect HD (similar to Aspect HD but for Vegas, and cheaper) but with Vegas 7's native m2t editing ability I'm not sure an intermediate codec is necessary in my situation.

     

    Any other views on 50i vs 60i?

    Edited by bubblevision
  4. So really the old argument of buying a Z1 because of its ability to record NTSC as well as PAL is redundant..

     

    Software can do the change for you ???

     

    Am I getting warmer ?

     

    Dive safe

     

    DeanB

  5. Well not really Dean because if you want to get hired to shoot then they're going to want you to shoot the right format.

  6. There is something wrong with the forum. So many times I have posted a post only to have it not appear.

    So I retype this one again..but a shorter version. <_<

     

    Nick you will soon get tired of editing in clunky m2t and what about colour correction.

     

    I would have a external hard drive, edit on the laptop then plug the drive into the desktop and grab a copy of the project file from the laptop and open it up on the desktop and the timeline should open up like you had on the laptop.

     

    Here are two clips encoded straight out of a PAL 50i EDIUS timeline.

     

    PAL m2t 45 megs

     

    NTSC m2t 45megs

     

    I never was real happy with Cineforms realtime Colour Correction for Aspect HD.

    Edited by wagsy
  7. There is something wrong with the forum. So many times I have posted a post only to have it not appear.

    So I retype this one again..but a shorter version. <_<

    Never had a problem here with this forum, maybe it's self-induction in the Exmouth marmalade circuit. Being anal, if I write a long post I try to remember to copy it to the clipboard or even paste to a notepad (rndNoter) just before I hit "Add reply" just in case things go pear-shaped. Been stung too much in the past on other forums.

     

    Nick you will soon get tired of editing in clunky m2t and what about colour correction.

    The improvement in native m2t editing was pretty much Sony's biggest upgrade feature from Vegas 6 to 7. In my experiments so far on my desktop PC it's very smooth indeed and not at all clunky. Maybe this is one area where Vegas shines for the time being over Prem Pro/Edius etc., but let's see when I get stuck into some real projects and colour correction. Connect HD is $199 so no point in buying it if I don't need to.

     

    I would have a external hard drive, edit on the laptop then plug the drive into the desktop and grab a copy of the project file from the laptop and open it up on the desktop and the timeline should open up like you had on the laptop.

    That's what I'll be doing and have always done since I got the desktop as well as the laptop. By the way I'm using a Western Digital 500Gb "MyBook" now and it's a great drive. Well thought out and the button manager is cool.

     

    Here are two clips encoded straight out of a PAL 50i EDIUS timeline.

     

    PAL m2t 45 megs

     

    NTSC m2t 45megs

    You mean an 1080i50 timeline, right? It's a very tricky one to judge here until I've got an HD monitor. Media Player Classic and VLC are stuggling with them at full res. They look the same in a half-res Vegas window.

    Edited by bubblevision
  8. Yes I sometimes copy the text to clipboard as well but not last time and got caught out. :)

     

    Have to read abit up about Vegas7, maybe they drop the res abit in the preview window so you can edit more in realtime then it goes to full res on rendering out the finshed file/timline.

     

    What does the button manager do on that drive?

  9. They don't drop the preview res, they've just put a lot of effort into optimising m2t editing.

     

    In Vegas preview window you can do 16 combinations: draft, preview, good or best at auto, full, half or quarter resolutions. Plus you can now choose whether to scale the video to fit. I'm currently editing at preview quality, half resolution and without the scale to fit. Plus you can output live on a Windows Secondary display. I've got a 2nd cheap Nvidia FX5200 graphics card with dual outputs and I'm going to monitor on a Benq 24" 1920x1200 monitor when they arrive in Thailand in a month or 2, as well as keeping my 2 x 17" monitors that I have now on my existing FX5200 dual card. That's the plan anyway.

     

    The WD drive has it's own firewire driver (that is installed when you first attach the drive via the USB option) which removes the drive properly when you press its big power button, as if you'd used the "safely remove hardware" route. It's a very stable drive (no more "delayed write failure" headaches) and phsically stable too and well vented no matter which way up you put it.

     

    Any other views on 50i vs 60i?

    Edited by bubblevision
  10. Ar yes, I just downloaded it and fired it up. Set it to full res and m2t slows it all down then but I see what you mean. Edius just shows the full res.

     

    Seems you have the cards sorted out as well.

     

    I got a NVIDIA Quadro FX 560 and Vegas overlayed out to the TV via Svideo for now but should have a high res screen soon to DVI to. Want to get a Core 2 Duo CPU then, like 4-5 tracks of 1440/1080 in moving pips with effects in real time. IN DV mode you would get like 10 tracks :)

     

    Driving my second screen from the motherboards onboard 128 meg VGA port.

     

    58.jpg

    No this is not Vegas.....

     

    http://www.dvfilm.com/products.htm have a few products to do conversions. I suppose you have been there for a read.

     

    Playing back full res m2t you need like 128 megs of graphics, even then one of my 128 meg driven screens plays them better than the other so not all cards are the same.

    Edited by wagsy
Turtle

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.