Decisions, decisions... I'm really torn about whether to shoot 1080i50 or 1080i60 with my new Z1. The liveaboard souvenir DVDs are still an important consideration for me but these days I'm primarily thinking of optimising for stock footage sales and my own productions.
Advantages of 50i
- Better picture quality (using the space saved by temporal resolution)
- Better transfer to film than 60i
- Native framerate for the majority of my liveaboard customers (so their PAL SD DVDs, which they'll continue to get for the next year or two, will be sharper)
- If transcoding is required, a 60fps encode from a 50i source is better than a 50fps encode from a 60i source (???)
Advantages of 60i
- Better temporal resolution (obviously) so better slo-mo etc.
- In general more international stock footage purchasers would prefer 60i (???)
- We're heading towards and era of 60p(?), so the footage will be more useable in the medium-longterm
- I can make SD NTSC DVDs for my liveaboard customers and the vast majority will be able to play them on their multi-system TVs. No more making 9 x PAL DVDs and 1 x NTSC DVD for the American/Japanese guy.
- Will convert more nicely to 15p which is perfect for web movies (conversely 12.5p half PAL is a little low)
That's how I'm seeing things at the moment and I'm leaning towards 60i. Any opinions? Any things I haven't considered? Any corrections to the above? Which framerate would NGC/Discovery/BBC prefer (leaving aside the need to upconvert)?
