Having read the disappointing review of KBR, I am a little concerned with our plans to go to Wakatobi which we are about to put down a deposit for. I will be going with a small group including a non diver and children. From all the discussion threads, I have come to the conclusion that the diving is fantastic, somewhat regimental dive guides. Has anyone been recently and can comment on what the living conditions and food are like? Similar to KBR, it is not a cheap holiday by any means, and I am a little worried of similar disappointing experience.

I was there, again, in September of this year and while I do believe the food was not as good as it has been in the past, there is no comparison between it and KBR. Wakatobi, in my opinion, has it all over KBR. The dive guides are a bit more enviromentaly concious than you will see in most other parts of Indonesia, but I don't believe that translates to regimental. To me it just means I won't be seeing someone with a stick digging a hole in the reef so some photog can get their shot.
The bungalow accomodations are superb, but the longhouse is not a place I would prefer, so be aware of the difference. The eats are very nice and a highlight of the food are the baked goods.
All in all you should not fear getting KBR service, food and accomodations at Wakatobi. It is a different level of resort entirely, though it is all about diving and little else. Pick your time of the year carefully, Wakatobi has some periods where those of you who don't dive might not like being stuck indoors because of the weather.