Skip to content

Photo / Video Showcase / Archived topic

I hate backscatter, but is it always bad?

Started by drsteve ·

  • 5Posts
  • 5Replies

Read-only discussion

I hate backscatter, but is it always bad?

5 posts
  1. This last weekend, I was on a 2 day trip on the Conception to the Channel Islands. I decided to practice exclusively wide angle since I need the practice, especially when the water isn't crystal clear. This image had hellacious backscatter. I worked with the healing tool to remove the more egregious problems, but the final image still has a lot. The effect, though is interesting. Just as film grain can evoke a gritty realistic feel to an image, the backscatter makes this image look like an oil painting. What do you think?

     

    The subject matter deserves some explanation. I witnessed a very rare event. On the backside of Santa Cruz, I found a juvenile Mola Mola that was the plaything of a band of Sealions. The Sealions tormented the poor thing and had chewed away his pectoral fins so that he was literally dead-in-the-water. The Mola was still alive, but not for much longer. The sealions didn't seem interested in eating it, just playing with it like cats play with mice.

     

    As usual, click on the image for more details.

     

    528750264_552ce0bb4a_o.jpg

    Edited by drsteve
  2. The image definitely makes one ask ' What's going on?' I imagine it is a fairly good representation of how things looked down there, so it works for me.

  3. try getting lower and shooting up more light from different angle. Amasing thing to see looks like it was quite murky. Tough enviroment to take action shoots

    well done though

  4. I think a little backscatter belongs in some pics, expecially sand creatures. I think many of us, me included, get caught up too much in Photoshop's capabilities :):)

  5. I think a little backscatter belongs in some pics, expecially sand creatures. I think many of us, me included, get caught up too much in Photoshop's capabilities :D:)

     

    Indeed we do...

     

    A quick look through David Doubilet's book Water Light Time reveals a number of images with heaps of backscatter, and they have plenty of personality, they work. There are other photos that are squeaky clean and appear to have made a quick layover in photoshop... I could be wrong though, that man is increadibly talented with his strobes (and camera)...

     

    As for the above photo: I like the backscatter, composition, and even the downward angle. however the complex and fascinating behavior shown doesn't quite come across with the birds eye view on the sunfish. I think there is much more emotion in the second photo on your flickr sight, it tells the story better. An increadible dive i'm sure! Cheers,

     

    Chris

Fotosub Shop

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.