Cold Water W/A, which do you prefer

So had a good day of viz, 15ft. So was playing with new Subtronic strobes and the Tokina 10-17. Trying to learn what pleasing to the eye with WA. What do you prefer?

I like the first one.

So had a good day of viz, 15ft. So was playing with new Subtronic strobes and the Tokina 10-17. Trying to learn what pleasing to the eye with WA. What do you prefer?

I like the first one too. The vis does look decent! I am thinking of doing a shore dive this weekend, where did you go? I'm always a little wary of Seattle water conditions in the summer.

Dave

This was taken at Edmonds. But I caught it on the high slack tide (?).

I like the first one too! Simply beautiful with this new lens.

I like the first one too! Simply beautiful with this new lens.

I prefer the third - the whole of the jelly is in the frame and I like the way that the fish are congregated around it. The first has a kelp stalk right up the centre of the frame which doesn't look right to me.

Tim

I like the 3rd one best. It feels more balanced and I like the background

Matt

I like the third. Maybe a bit less darkness on the bottom but I like the feel of it. It lets you see the whole environment that the jelly exists within yet still see the fish too.

Cheers

Todd