Macro Lens

I am considering one of these lens in my D-200/Subal system to get back to the "old 60 macro film" range.

Any one have experience with either of these and what are your opinions?

Thanks in advance .............

To get back the old 60 macro film, get an old 60 macro for your D200.

There´s already a thread about this two guys you´r asking for, and many for the 17-70 itself:

http://wetpixel.com/forums/index.php?showt...90&hl=18-50