Skip to content

Shooting Technique, Workflow and Editing / Archived topic

Camera Raw and JPGs in CS3

Started by AndreSmith ·

  • 3Posts
  • 3Replies

Read-only discussion

Camera Raw and JPGs in CS3

3 posts
  1. I have just upgraded to CS3 ( forced to as CS2 wont read my Canon 40D raw files :) ) I notice that you can now open and adjust JPGs in Adobe Camera Raw. My question is whether that is better than opening the JPG directly in Photoshop and adjusting it there. And if so, does that negate the advantages of shooting RAW over JPGs in the first place?

  2. More infor in RAW than JPEGs = better pixs in my opinion

    JPEGS + RAW converter in CS3 = better jpeg control

  3. JPEG: 8 bits/channel of information in each pixel

     

    RAW: Starts out at 12 bits per channel in each pixel; then is saved to a TIFF or PSD at 16 bits/channel per pixel, allowing far superior gradiations.

     

    [Then, convert to 8 bits right before saving as a JPEG.]

     

    Starting with Photoshop 9, err, CS2, Thomas Knoll changed the sharpening in the ACR 3 converter to sharpen only the luminosity channel, i.e. it works by converting from RGB to LAB color space, selects only the luminosity channel, and more aggressively sharpens just that, so that color noise is not sharpened.

     

    I have just upgraded to CS3 ( forced to as CS2 wont read my Canon 40D raw files -_- ) I notice that you can now open and adjust JPGs in Adobe Camera Raw. My question is whether that is better than opening the JPG directly in Photoshop and adjusting it there. And if so, does that negate the advantages of shooting RAW over JPGs in the first place?
Backscatter

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.