Skip to content

Lights, Strobes, and Lighting Technique / Archived topic

Best strobes for macro ???

Started by frisco ·

  • 12Posts
  • 12Replies

Read-only discussion

Best strobes for macro ???

12 posts
  1. I’m interested in adding a ring flash to my kit (Canon 450D + Hugyfot housing + Hugyfot port FLP-6.100 + Canon 60 F2.8 macro USM + Inon D2000 type 2 strobe); to the best of my understanding the only ring flash models available on the consumer market are INON Z22 and ATHENA ARF10. Does anyone have any experience with these units ??? The INON as a 22 guide number .... Does anyone now the ATHENA guide number ??? I assume it should be lower considering the price gap between the two units (ATHENA € 700 - INON € 950). I doubt both units could be fixed to my flat port, so I’ll have to figure out an arm system to position them in front of the port.

     

    Would the ring flash set up be an advantage compared to a double strobe set up ??? Would it be a waste of money and I should stay with my single INON D2000 strobe positioned just above my port ??? Should I add a second INON strobe (D2000 or Z240) and positon both strobes to the side of my port ???

     

    Any input or advice is very much welcome !!!!

     

    Francesco

  2. Add a 2nd Inon. I think that gives you the most flexibility with your lighting. With a 100 degrees of coverage on each side of your port I really don't think you'll be getting any less effective light. But I'm not an expert either. Maybe there is some advantage I'm not thinking about with a ringflash.

  3. I would add a second Inon strobe. I have been told ring flashes are great for close macros, but lack in power. In other words, two Z240s would give much more available strobe light than a ring flash so you could shoot at a larger number f stop and get greater depth of field or shoot a subject further away from your lens than you could with just a ring flash.

     

    Elmer

  4. I find the Inon Z22 to be pretty powerful, sometimes for really close shots, too powerful so I use it on 1/4 and 1/2 power much of the time. I alternate between using 2 Z220's, the Z22, and sometimes I use both the Z22 and one Z-220. The drawback to the Inon Z22 (and Z220) is that it is not ttl, at least with my setup, so you gotta go manual only, which is not a big deal though. Another drawback is you may need a special port to use it, but the upside is that it does make for a nice, small package to work with underwater.

  5. Hi Francesco,

     

    I use the Athena ring-flash for about 85% of my macro work and at distances of about two inches (50 mm) to about eighteen inches (450 mm). The lenses I use range from 70 to 200 mm in 35 mm terms and run from 1:1 to 2:1, I also use wet diopters. I shoot at ISO 100 and from F/11 to F/32 without exposure issues. The upsides to the Athena ring-flash are its small size, the fact that it can be made to work with about any macro port and the fact that you can control power by turing a dial up and down through the full power range, (unlike the Inon Z-22 which has three power settings). Downsides are that it only works in manual (not a large problem), it is not as robust as the Inon Z-22 and it only uses two AA batteries, unlike the Inon which takes four batteries and has faster recycle times. I also use two Inon Z-240 strobes for the rest of my macro. Its clear that the Inon Z-22 ring-flash was designed for film photographers and needs to be updated. I hope that at some point Inon will redesign their ring-flash to work in S-TTL and reduce its size as they have with the smaller S-2000 strobes which were shown at DEMA.

     

    Phil Rudin

  6. Hi,

     

    I am also researching ring lights for a possible purchase. Are there now any units other than the Athena ARF10 and the Inon? I agree the Athena unit is a little underpowered and slow (based on specs alone, as I do not own one). So I wonder about the potential to use the ring from the Athena ARF10 unit, but modify another more powerful strobe, such as an Iklelite DS51, to supply the power. (For example, remove flash tube from DS51 and connect the wires feeding the flash tube to the ring via compatible cable.) Then it could also operate in TTL with compatible digital cameras.

     

    UW3D

     

     

     

    I'm interested in adding a ring flash to my kit (Canon 450D + Hugyfot housing + Hugyfot port FLP-6.100 + Canon 60 F2.8 macro USM + Inon D2000 type 2 strobe); to the best of my understanding the only ring flash models available on the consumer market are INON Z22 and ATHENA ARF10. Does anyone have any experience with these units ??? The INON as a 22 guide number .... Does anyone now the ATHENA guide number ??? I assume it should be lower considering the price gap between the two units (ATHENA € 700 - INON € 950). I doubt both units could be fixed to my flat port, so I'll have to figure out an arm system to position them in front of the port.

     

    Would the ring flash set up be an advantage compared to a double strobe set up ??? Would it be a waste of money and I should stay with my single INON D2000 strobe positioned just above my port ??? Should I add a second INON strobe (D2000 or Z240) and positon both strobes to the side of my port ???

     

    Any input or advice is very much welcome !!!!

     

    Francesco

     

    Hi,

     

    I am also researching ring lights for a possible purchase. Are there now any units other than the Athena ARF10 and the Inon? I agree the Athena unit is a little underpowered and slow (based on specs alone, as I do not own one). So I wonder about the potential to use the ring from the Athena ARF10 unit, but modify another more powerful strobe, such as an Iklelite DS51, to supply the power. (For example, remove flash tube from DS51 and connect the wires feeding the flash tube to the ring via compatible cable.) Then it could also operate in TTL with compatible digital cameras.

     

    UW3D

     

    Hi Francesco,

     

    I use the Athena ring-flash for about 85% of my macro work and at distances of about two inches (50 mm) to about eighteen inches (450 mm). The lenses I use range from 70 to 200 mm in 35 mm terms and run from 1:1 to 2:1, I also use wet diopters. I shoot at ISO 100 and from F/11 to F/32 without exposure issues. The upsides to the Athena ring-flash are its small size, the fact that it can be made to work with about any macro port and the fact that you can control power by turing a dial up and down through the full power range, (unlike the Inon Z-22 which has three power settings). Downsides are that it only works in manual (not a large problem), it is not as robust as the Inon Z-22 and it only uses two AA batteries, unlike the Inon which takes four batteries and has faster recycle times. I also use two Inon Z-240 strobes for the rest of my macro. Its clear that the Inon Z-22 ring-flash was designed for film photographers and needs to be updated. I hope that at some point Inon will redesign their ring-flash to work in S-TTL and reduce its size as they have with the smaller S-2000 strobes which were shown at DEMA.

     

    Phil Rudin

  7. Hi,

     

    I am also researching ring lights for a possible purchase. Are there now any units other than the Athena ARF10 and the Inon? I agree the Athena unit is a little underpowered and slow (based on specs alone, as I do not own one). So I wonder about the potential to use the ring from the Athena ARF10 unit, but modify another more powerful strobe, such as an Iklelite DS51, to supply the power. (For example, remove flash tube from DS51 and connect the wires feeding the flash tube to the ring via compatible cable.) Then it could also operate in TTL with compatible digital cameras.

    I have both the Athena and the Inon and they are quite different beasts. The Inon won't do TTL even though Matthias says he has made it work, and is much more powerful than the Athena. The Athena does indeed have a fully controllable power output but at full power and two newly charged batteries it still takes 5 seconds to recycle. The Inon is bigger and mounts to a special port. I had a Subal port made by a brit and it is very neat. If I am shooting the Canon 100, I will take the Inon since the port is made for the 100. If I am shooting the 60, I will take the Athena and one Z240 or sometimes even two. I like the idea of triggering the z240 from the camera and using the optical trigger on the Athena. That way you can add a bit of shadow to some pictures if you need a bit more creative lighting than you get simply from the ring.

    Both the Inon and the Athena can take add on lenses that screw into the front of the strobe itself. The Inon one is a weird thread, and is a plus2 or so. The athena has a threaded 67 mm front port so you can screw in any 67 mm wet diopter.

     

    So overall IMHO the Athena is smaller and much slower recycling, with considerable less power. They claim a GN of 16 at 1/2 meter but in pool tests it is about 2 full stops maybe more less power than the Inon. The Athena is also less heavy and bulky which is of some consideration now days. The battery cap on the Athena is quite cheap, and bends easily but I have not had any water ingress issues at all. Both strobes can do the job, depends on if you are in the shoot shoot shoot mode (Inon) or in the more contemplative mode (Athena)

    Bill

  8. Bill,

     

    I see you have a 50D. Canon says in Live View mode the camera will not fire a non-Canon strobe. Do you know if your 50D will fire the Athena ring light? If so, does that require some conversin circuitry in your housing or elsewhere?

     

    Mark

  9. Bill,

     

    I see you have a 50D. Canon says in Live View mode the camera will not fire a non-Canon strobe. Do you know if your 50D will fire the Athena ring light? If so, does that require some conversin circuitry in your housing or elsewhere?

     

    Mark

    Never tried it in Liveview, I'll get back to you when my housing gets back from Ryan, who is making it work with Optical.

    BVA

  10. Never tried it in Liveview, I'll get back to you when my housing gets back from Ryan, who is making it work with Optical.

    BVA

     

    Great. look forward to hearing about it. Thank you.

  11. Hi,

     

    I would like to share a picture I took with the Athena ARF 10 ring flash. As Phil pointed out, it's only manual and takes some trial and error to find the right exposure.

     

     

    Pygmy_seahorse.jpg

     

    Edward Lai

  12. Francesco, you rascal! Stop this otherwise I have to tell Daniella. Ringflash indeed. I have a Z-220 I can sell you.... ;-)

Nauticam

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.