Thanks all, the gallery is up at our site for those interested and now on to reviewing the +10hrs of video we shot...
I will write a full trip report but probably won't be for a couple of weeks soooo.....The house reef at Wakatobi is by far the best we have seen anywhere! I could have dived it the whole trip and never gotten bored. Many want to compare it to Raja but now seeing both I just don't think that is fair. To me Raja is the best all-around diving we have seen. I would say Wakatobi has better topography and EVERY INCH is covered in incredible corals and fans; but Raja has more diverse fish and invert life. That said another photog on our trip shot his 105mm most of the time, found 12 species of nudis and a ton of macro that I never saw as I was so taken with the WA vistas.
What I came to respect is how hard Wakatobi has worked with the locals to establish this as a dive spot and is doing to preserve the health of this reef. No gloves, no tripods, they "ask" you don't fire 20 photos in a row of the pygmy seahorse and they tell you up front if you want a shot that needs to be steadied use the dive guide as your tripod. They mean it and the guides are happy to do it. Now they are not dive police, the only time I saw them intervene is when one photog was trying to position a large mantis shrimp with his finger for a better shot. I don't think he realized that is a good way to lose a finger and the guides explained that to him on deck. Reality is if you see a good shot from Wakatobi it was taken in the way that all images should be taken, with respect for the reef and its creatures.
I used the Kenko 1.4 N-AF Teleplus Pro 300. Seemed to work fine with the Tokina a little slow on my Nikon 105mm VR
Water temp was around 80 degrees, I wore a 3mm the whole time and was plenty warm. But that is a very personal thing.
Yes we loved Wakatobi, great diving, great resort, excellent food, class operation from start to finish. Only hassle is analyzing 8 tanks every morning.