Skip to content

Video Gear and Technique / Archived topic

Switching from HDV to DSLR for video only

Started by RandyTravis ·

  • 10Posts
  • 10Replies

Read-only discussion

Switching from HDV to DSLR for video only

10 posts
  1. Hello, I have been an underwater videographer for about a year, making videos for divers as well as stock footage. You can see some of my stuff here:

     

    I am going to buy the new Canon Rebel T2i for stock video on land and am considering it for UW as well, but I have a few questions. Currently I use a Sony HVR-V1U in an equinox housing no lights just a filter. I am worried if I switch to the DSLR I will have problems holding the camera steady for shots because of the shape of those housings, also only being able to use 1 lens on the dive, I need to be able to film the divers for the job at the dive shop but I want to be able to go in and do some macro stuff also, guess maybe thats not possible with DSLR.

     

    Please let me know all of your thoughts on DSLR advantages and disadvantages also housings you reccomend.

     

    Thanks,

    Randy

  2. Hi Randy, and welcome to Wetpixel!

     

    This thread has some great discussion about ViDslr use including this nice quote from Ladygodiver

    edit....The more I use the 5D2 the more impressed I am with how it lends itself for the way I need to shoot video...in a more controlled and disciplined way....edit

     

    It's worth reading that whole thread to get a feel for the pros and cons of these systems.

     

    But in a nutshell, theViDslr cameras certainly aren't "point and shoot" camcorders. The best results seem to be when they are used with care, and to their strengths.

     

    I've come from the stills arena into video on a 5DmkII, but have only shot available light, wide angle which has been quite straightforward, but I'm sure others with wider experience in the area you're working in will be able to chime in with their opinions.

  3. Hello, I have been an underwater videographer for about a year, making videos for divers as well as stock footage. You can see some of my stuff here:

     

    I am going to buy the new Canon Rebel T2i for stock video on land and am considering it for UW as well, but I have a few questions. Currently I use a Sony HVR-V1U in an equinox housing no lights just a filter. I am worried if I switch to the DSLR I will have problems holding the camera steady for shots because of the shape of those housings, also only being able to use 1 lens on the dive, I need to be able to film the divers for the job at the dive shop but I want to be able to go in and do some macro stuff also, guess maybe thats not possible with DSLR.

     

    Please let me know all of your thoughts on DSLR advantages and disadvantages also housings you reccomend.

     

    Thanks,

    Randy

     

     

    Hey Randy, welcome.

     

    The T2i is new and Ikelite is the closest to having one released (if it hasn't been yet.) Nauticam had drawings of their housing at Beneath The Sea.

     

    There have been a bunch of threads where people have gone back and forth on the pros and cons of a dedicated video camera vs the vDSLR, grabbed a couple of them

     

    http://wetpixel.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=35106

     

    http://wetpixel.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=33931

     

    http://wetpixel.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=34238

     

    Some more here on the 5D and video (though the search is a bit broad)

     

    Overall there has been some real impressive footage, but not without caveats. One seems to be stability with the current set-ups/holding steady as you suggested. Another is that people have mentioned that for Macro lenses, a tripod is a must. Also the lens issue as you mentioned (not a limit but more the nature of the beast.) Also WB is not as easy on the vDSLRs.

     

    Though the vDSLs can really do a nice job, and are better than many cameras, more so on the consumer end, and can hold their own against other video cameras, the camera you shot may be a better bet to continue to work with based on what you described you are doing and the quality of the camera you are shooting. I would think a set of lights would be a better bet for you right now as oppossed to housing the T2i.

  4. Hi, I think you'd be better off using your V1 for stock, it's a far more capable video camera than a DSLR with video add-on...

    Maybe upgrade your housing?

    Just my two cents worth

     

    Cheers

     

    Richard

  5. Also have a look at the thread:

     

    http://wetpixel.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=34790

     

    My own experience going from HDV to DSLRs (Canon 5D2 & 7D) has been painless and very positive. Sure, its perhaps not as easy to use as a HDV camcorder...and it requires a more disciplined approach to videography. But, the end result is outstanding.

     

    HDV was a great format in its day. It made HD videography accessible to all. However, the limitations of the codec are becoming more apparent as the new DSLRs gain acceptance.

     

    So what are the advantages of using a DSLR?

     

    1) A superior codec (mpeg4 @ 38 mbps vs mpeg2 @ 25 mbps). A VERY noticable on screen difference if a carefully controlled comparison is made (which I did before committing to DSLRs).

     

    2) A much bigger imaging chip. Better for low light and gives a "better" cinematic look due to the lower Depth of Field.

     

    Sure, "aliasing" is a problem with the current DSLR video technology...but this is more of an issue for topside work than underwater. As the image processors in DSLRs get more powerful, aliasing will probably cease to be an issue.

     

    3) Need to work like a film cinematographer...forget Auto Focus; forget zooming. Yes, I consider this an advantage...it makes one work in a more controlled way.

     

    4) Glass...glass...glass. The choice of superb lenses (prime or zoom) is fantastic. Far better quality than putting converters on a "one size fits all" camcorder zoom. Also, lens based Image Stabilization works well with the Canons. Some zooms allow wide-angle to macro on the same dive.

     

    5) Ability to do HD video or pro quality still photography on the same dive.

     

    6) NLE of .mov files is not difficult if converted to an intermediate (eg Canopus HQ). Very soon Adobe Premier CS5 with the "Mercury Engine" will enable native editing on a high end machine. As computers get more powerful, this will become a non-issue.

     

    The good news is that the limitations of HDV are less apparent underwater. With careful editing and color grading HDV can mix reasonably well with DSLR scenes. If you can't decide which way to go run both systems together for a while and decide which is for you!

     

    Another looming alternative is the new Canon pro quality camcorder which will use the Canon's new mpeg2 codec. This should be a very nice alternative option when released in 2011.

  6. I've been shooting a V1/Gates combo for a couple of years now and I've been shooting a 7D topside for the last 6 months or so. I am now about to get a housing for the 7D, but that is mainly due to the fact that my wife Zoe shoots stills, I don't think I'd be buying a housing just to shoot video underwater on the 7D. After 6 months of shooting with it I've finally begun to understand how to get the best out of the 7D in a variety of scenarios (ie not just on a tripod), but it will never be a 'camcorder' so you will always have to compromise. If you want 7D quality in a 'camcorder' package then it is already available - just look at the EX1 or EX3, although admittedly a hell of a lot more expensive! I love the 7D and I'm planning on taking it on a trip in a few months time solely to shoot video and see how I get on. Hey perhaps I'll be eating my words after that - it actually would be a great result if that was the case! :goodpost:

     

    Cheers, Simon

  7. I am now about to get a housing for the 7D, but that is mainly due to the fact that my wife Zoe shoots stills,

     

    Mainly due to the fact that Zoe has, shall we say, asked nicely ;):dunno::goodpost:

     

    Dive safe

     

    DeanB

  8. 3) Need to work like a film cinematographer...forget Auto Focus; forget zooming. Yes, I consider this an advantage...it makes one work in a more controlled way.

     

    Tons of amazing topside video out there shot with 5d and 7d. Footage that can't be matched by consumer camcorders. Can't say the same for underwater. Maybe not enough people shooting underwater or maybe the strengths can't really be taken advantage of underwater ?

     

    I'm really like my 7d for topside video. However, I'm keeping my Sony FX7 and Gates housing for underwater use. On the fly manual white balance, instant push auto focus, 20x zoom for macro, housing well balanced/trimmed, ND filters, etc..

     

    Controlled scenes and environment is much easier topside than underwater.

    Edited by ronscuba
  9. Agreed Ron. Sometimes you have to compromise between getting that perfect shot or getting the shot at all.

     

    Dean yes she asked very nicely! :goodpost:

     

    Cheers, Simon

  10. If you prefer the advantages of a camcorder, have a look at the new Panasonic TM700. I just bought one as a backup for the 5D2 (got rid of the Canon 7D).

     

    It does 60p @ 28mbps AVCHD (same as mpeg 2 @ 50 mbps) and has excellent sharpness and color rendition. No alaising issues, good AF and stabilization. Manual control of audio (the big issue with the 7D).

     

    In decent light it even seems to have better resolution than a Sony EX1/3 (although I haven't compared them myself):

     

     

    Panasonic TM700 vs Sony XDCAM EX3

     

    http://camcorder-test.slashcam.com/campair-EN.shtml

     

    Panasonic TM700 vs Sony XDCAM EX1

     

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6lMByIVeMA0...feature=related

     

    Maybe even good enough for the BBC...

Scuba.com

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.