Skip to content

Video Gear and Technique / Archived topic

5DmkII used to shoot season finale of "House"

Started by photovan ·

  • 13Posts
  • 13Replies

Read-only discussion

5DmkII used to shoot season finale of "House"

13 posts
  1. oh and this feature film ...

    Edited by Giles
  2. I have a Canon 7d and find it amazing to use topside. I'm not convinced DSLR's are ready to replace camcorders underwater. Can the strengths and advantages be applied UW ? Either way, I'm not totally surprised about the 5d and House.

     

    Here are 2 videos on Vimeo that were shot with the 5d and 7d.

     

    [vimeo]9856236[/vimeo]

    [vimeo]10570139[/vimeo]

     

     

    5d body costs $2500, 7d $1700, new T2i costs $800. Amazing.

  3. I have a Canon 7d and find it amazing to use topside. I'm not convinced DSLR's are ready to replace camcorders underwater. Can the strengths and advantages be applied UW ?

     

     

    Why not? The camera itself is superb for underwater videography.

     

    Unmatched (even RED doesn't come close) for low light capability.

     

    The only serious issue, aliasing, is a non-issue underwater since the type of subject/pattern that causes aliasing doesn't occur much in nature.

     

    Editing native .mov is now a breeze with the new NLEs (eg EDIUS 5.5) that are appearing.

     

    The low DOF gives the medium range subjects a "dimensionality", ie they stand out from the background, that can't be achieved with small chip cameras. But...if you do want lots of DOF, put on another lens (eg Canon 14mm f2.8) and you can virtually forget about needing to focus.

     

    Zoom...with a good housing, it's possible to zoom manually.

     

    Sure, can't autofocus with the Canons...who cares. Even the best camcorder's AF usually ends up ruining mid-water scenes with bouts of "hunting". The quick "AF acquire" on the Canon is far better and very quick.

     

    Image stabilization works very well.

     

    The main problem seems to be the housings. They all seem to be made from a still photographer's perspective...hence the stability and handling issues.

     

    A good housing for this camera needs: 1) A video on/off trigger release (not a push button on the back!); 2) An external monitor (which no one seems to provide yet); 3)Decent video lighting (just because the camera is low light capable doesn't mean it performs optimally with low power lighting).

     

     

    As far as the Canon 5D2/7D being used for major production, have a look at:

     

    http://hurlbutvisuals.com/blog/

     

    This guy is a serious player...who also was a cinematographer for the movie "Into the Blue".

     

     

    edit: hey...I didn't realize one of the vimeo movies was from Hurlbut's blog!

    Edited by HDVdiver
  4. Who remembers the bagging this camera got when first discussed on Wetpixel?

     

    I do and how silly to get since Scarlet was still right around the corner. I bought my 5D Mark II about 14 months after the initial announcement of Scarlet and have had my 5D Mark II for about 10 months. I feel real silly buying the 5D Mark II ;) I actually have not upgraded the firmware yet to the newest release, need to get around to that.

     

    A couple of firmware updates later and....

    this article appears today on engadget

     

    Going to make sure to watch that one. Very cool.

  5. How's the housing situation looking for the 5DII and 7D?

  6. Why not? .....

     

    There is another thread discussing the + and - of DSLR underwater. No single correct answer for everyone. At least for me, as a hobbyist, I will keep using my Sony FX7 and Gates housing for UW.

     

    As primarily a vacation diver, my UW shooting is all based on opportunity. The ability to do things quickly is important. Focus, manual white balance, ND filters, zooming, balanced rig, external tiltable monitor. All adjusted instantly. I should clarify the issue of focus. On my FX7 and many other pro-sumer camcorders, there is a "push-auto-focus" button. Push and hold the button in, the camcorder auto focuses. Release the button, it locks into manual focus. It's a great feature for UW video.

     

    Shallow depth of field from the camera is not super important to me UW. We already get a little of that effect from the water itself. Currently, what attracts me to DSLR for underwater is the low light and dynamic range. However, for me, that feature is not enough to overcome the other weaknesses compared to my camcorder.

    Edited by ronscuba
  7. There is another thread discussing the + and - of DSLR underwater. No single correct answer for everyone. At least for me, as a hobbyist, I will keep using my Sony FX7 and Gates housing for UW.

     

    As primarily a vacation diver, my UW shooting is all based on opportunity. The ability to do things quickly is important. Focus, manual white balance, ND filters, zooming, balanced rig, external tiltable monitor. All adjusted instantly. I should clarify the issue of focus. On my FX7 and many other pro-sumer camcorders, there is a "push-auto-focus" button. Push and hold the button in, the camcorder auto focuses. Release the button, it locks into manual focus. It's a great feature for UW video.

     

    Shallow depth of field from the camera is not super important to me UW. We already get a little of that effect from the water itself. Currently, what attracts me to DSLR for underwater is the low light and dynamic range. However, for me, that feature is not enough to overcome the other weaknesses compared to my camcorder.

     

    I'm with you Ron at the moment, 5D and 7D are great tools for certain circumstances but not for my majority of use underwater, the H.264 acquisition is still a big bug bear for me also.

  8. I'm with you Ron at the moment, 5D and 7D are great tools for certain circumstances but not for my majority of use underwater, the H.264 acquisition is still a big bug bear for me also.

     

     

    I agree that using a Canon 5D2/7D underwater isn't for everyone. Perhaps it's more for those who are thinking of upgrading to "RED" or "Scarlet"...or an EX3.

     

    It's actually a major problem for those unable to do the serious modifications to available housings that are required to make them as functional as a dedicated camcorder. Hopefully housing manufacturers will eventually produce designs that are more ergonomic for videographers.

     

    Coming from years of using HDV Sonys in Gates and Amphibico housings, it was a major leap of faith (and financial outlay). Going over to Canon (I've been a Nikon user for 35 years and had a lot of their glass) was another thing I had to get my head around!

     

    After serveral months of using the 5D2 underwater I'm very happy with what it can do. In terms of IQ on the screen, I personally feel it's worth the effort of shooting "differently".

     

    H.264 need no longer be a problem. It's actually a very efficient codec...and the new NLEs make native .mov editing and final render to high def MPEG2 (or what ever you need) easy on a modest Quadcore machine.

    Edited by HDVdiver
  9. How's the housing situation looking for the 5DII and 7D?

     

     

    You probably saw the comparison Gudge did between the Aquatica and the Nauticam for the 7D. http://wetpixel.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=35507

     

    Short version is that the Nauticam has the video controls on the right side of the housing right under your thumb. Subal appears to also have the Start/Stop record under the thumb in easy reach. Sea & Sea will be out in May? and would also appear to use roughly the same control setup (only pictures so far).

     

    I've been playing with my Nauticam in the pool and it's an impressive piece of gear. Lots of good choices for housings.

     

    I'm working on using some spare arms and clamps to rig a "gunstock" steady cam type setup. There are so many possible attach points on the housing there has to be a configuration that works. Just have to talk ULCS into making us a handle.

     

    Steve

  10. Short version is that the Nauticam has the video controls on the right side of the housing right under your thumb. Subal appears to also have the Start/Stop record under the thumb in easy reach. Sea & Sea will be out in May? and would also appear to use roughly the same control setup (only pictures so far).

     

    Steve

     

     

    Yes a thumb release is better than the "push button" on Nexus and others...I still prefer a conventional trigger type of release. This could easily be done via an minature infrared controller inside the housing linked to the same trigger as for still photos. That's how I've set my unit up.

     

    I think the silly USB/video plug on the 7D is going to make life difficult for anyone who wants to fit a SD monitor...it certainly isn't as straightforward as the 3.5 mini plug on the 5D2. If anyone knows where to get a compact, right-angled Canon type "USB" to 3.5mm Video cable I'd really like to get one. The cable that Canon provide with the 7D is too big for most housings...and successfully modifying it seems to be impossible.

    Edited by HDVdiver
  11. Opps didn't even see this thread. FYI the first scene in Episode 17 of House, Lockdown, was also shot with the 5D2 and 100mm macro L.

    Edited by Drew
  12. Here's a link to Phillip Bloom's interview with the Exec Producer and Director of the House season finale

Reef Photo & Video

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.