I want to start shooting video seriously with my Canon 5Dmk2 and trying to find the best "affordable" video lighting solution out there at an affordable price. But also, there are not many reviews or recommendations on the net as to the best lighting solution for this application. The options I have found are the following:
1. Nocturnal Lights - the 800i are options.
2. Luna series - these look awesome but way too expensive.
3. Hartenberger - have the Video MAxi lighting set which looks quite good, also compact to fit under and on the slr housing.
4. BossK lights - they have video lights which look effective and well-built. Details are good but look bulky and not sure will fit under the housing without making a huge bulk underneath and make the application uncomfortable.
5. Light & Motion lights - expensive but should be good lights.
Can anyone comment on these options, add to the list, recommend, suggest based on thier experiences etc
Thanks
Anthony
I use a Canon 5D2 with the HDVSEATEK LED2500 lights show in the picture below.
Although a Canon 5D2 has the best low light capability...it also has a VERY narrow depth of field. Hence, I feel it's important to use lights of moderate to high lumen output (ie 2000 to 3000 Lumens) in order to allow use of a higher F-stop. This is particularly true for macro work...try this with a Canon VidDSLR and low power lights and the shallowness of the DOF will make things very difficult.
For shadow free WA or Macro shooting, two lights will always produce a nicer result than one.
Also, use of moderate power lights with a VideoDSLR has the added benefit of not requiring extra strobes for still photos...the same lights will work perfectly for video or still.
Compare different manufacturer's lights in terms of:
* Lumen output ...but matched for beam angle (ie 1000 Lumens @ 70 degrees is a lot less powerful than 1000 Lumens @ 100 degrees). How accurate is the claim.
* Are they using the latest generation LED technology in terms of Lumens per Watt efficiency.
* Color temperature...5000 Kelvin to 6000 Kelvin...and how accurate is the claim. Any higher it's too blue, any lower it's too warm...and harder to balance with daylight.
* CRI...and how accurate is the claim.
* Beam angle ...and how even the light is (no hotspots). Have a look at examples on the web (even on Wetpixel)...or their website.
* LED emitter redundancy...if the control electronics fail, do you lose all the light output...or just a few LEDs. Is it double or triple redundancy?
* O-ring sealing...single or double. LEDs are robust but very expensive to repair if flooded (unlike HID). Double O-ring sealing is very useful redundancy.
* Depth rating.
* Are the lights totally self-contained with integrated batteries...or are they pod/cable/light head designs.
* Lumen/weight ratio (ideally 1...ie 2500L/2500 grams=1; 1000L/1000g=1).
* Controls...magnetic ....or shaft/o-ring switch...or rubber toggle.
* Burn time (what's the minimum you personally need at FULL power to cover the duration of an average night dive).
* Battery technology & safety issues...air travel considerations/restrictions in different parts of the world.
* Warranty...do you get your money back if you're not happy with the lights.
