Skip to content

Video Gear and Technique / Archived topic

Best video lights for VidSLR shooting

Started by seacamera ·

  • 15Posts
  • 15Replies

Read-only discussion

Best video lights for VidSLR shooting

15 posts
  1. I want to start shooting video seriously with my Canon 5Dmk2 and trying to find the best "affordable" video lighting solution out there at an affordable price. But also, there are not many reviews or recommendations on the net as to the best lighting solution for this application. The options I have found are the following:

     

    1. Nocturnal Lights - the 800i are options.

    2. Luna series - these look awesome but way too expensive.

    3. Hartenberger - have the Video MAxi lighting set which looks quite good, also compact to fit under and on the slr housing.

    4. BossK lights - they have video lights which look effective and well-built. Details are good but look bulky and not sure will fit under the housing without making a huge bulk underneath and make the application uncomfortable.

    5. Light & Motion lights - expensive but should be good lights.

     

    Can anyone comment on these options, add to the list, recommend, suggest based on thier experiences etc

     

    Thanks

    Anthony

  2. I want to start shooting video seriously with my Canon 5Dmk2 and trying to find the best "affordable" video lighting solution out there at an affordable price. But also, there are not many reviews or recommendations on the net as to the best lighting solution for this application. The options I have found are the following:

     

    1. Nocturnal Lights - the 800i are options.

    2. Luna series - these look awesome but way too expensive.

    3. Hartenberger - have the Video MAxi lighting set which looks quite good, also compact to fit under and on the slr housing.

    4. BossK lights - they have video lights which look effective and well-built. Details are good but look bulky and not sure will fit under the housing without making a huge bulk underneath and make the application uncomfortable.

    5. Light & Motion lights - expensive but should be good lights.

     

    Can anyone comment on these options, add to the list, recommend, suggest based on thier experiences etc

     

    Thanks

    Anthony

     

     

    I use a Canon 5D2 with the HDVSEATEK LED2500 lights show in the picture below.

     

    Although a Canon 5D2 has the best low light capability...it also has a VERY narrow depth of field. Hence, I feel it's important to use lights of moderate to high lumen output (ie 2000 to 3000 Lumens) in order to allow use of a higher F-stop. This is particularly true for macro work...try this with a Canon VidDSLR and low power lights and the shallowness of the DOF will make things very difficult.

     

    For shadow free WA or Macro shooting, two lights will always produce a nicer result than one.

     

    Also, use of moderate power lights with a VideoDSLR has the added benefit of not requiring extra strobes for still photos...the same lights will work perfectly for video or still.

     

    Compare different manufacturer's lights in terms of:

     

    * Lumen output ...but matched for beam angle (ie 1000 Lumens @ 70 degrees is a lot less powerful than 1000 Lumens @ 100 degrees). How accurate is the claim.

     

    * Are they using the latest generation LED technology in terms of Lumens per Watt efficiency.

     

    * Color temperature...5000 Kelvin to 6000 Kelvin...and how accurate is the claim. Any higher it's too blue, any lower it's too warm...and harder to balance with daylight.

     

    * CRI...and how accurate is the claim.

     

    * Beam angle ...and how even the light is (no hotspots). Have a look at examples on the web (even on Wetpixel)...or their website.

     

    * LED emitter redundancy...if the control electronics fail, do you lose all the light output...or just a few LEDs. Is it double or triple redundancy?

     

    * O-ring sealing...single or double. LEDs are robust but very expensive to repair if flooded (unlike HID). Double O-ring sealing is very useful redundancy.

     

    * Depth rating.

     

    * Are the lights totally self-contained with integrated batteries...or are they pod/cable/light head designs.

     

    * Lumen/weight ratio (ideally 1...ie 2500L/2500 grams=1; 1000L/1000g=1).

     

    * Controls...magnetic ....or shaft/o-ring switch...or rubber toggle.

     

    * Burn time (what's the minimum you personally need at FULL power to cover the duration of an average night dive).

     

    * Battery technology & safety issues...air travel considerations/restrictions in different parts of the world.

     

    * Warranty...do you get your money back if you're not happy with the lights.

    post-16448-1274402352.jpg

    Edited by HDVdiver
  3. I use a Canon 5D2 with the HDVSEATEK LED2500 lights show in the picture below.

     

    Would that be because you sell them? :D I'm not sure $2400 US would count as affordable for most folks. I'm sure they are great lights if you say so. Do you have any shots of them next to something for size comparison. They look huge in the photo.

     

    I'm curious about the new Light & Motion light too. Has anyone dove it yet?

     

     

    Cheers,

    Steve

  4. Would that be because you sell them? :D I'm not sure $2400 US would count as affordable for most folks. I'm sure they are great lights if you say so. Do you have any shots of them next to something for size comparison. They look huge in the photo.

     

    I'm curious about the new Light & Motion light too.

     

     

     

     

    Cheers,

    Steve

     

     

    Think of it in terms of ...I sell them because I use them...:D

     

    You get what you pay for...and it's a lot less than US$3799.

     

    They are only 2.1 Kg in weight and neutral underwater...same size as the old Nikon SB104 strobe...or the current Ikelite Substrobe DS200.

     

    The comparison points I've listed are valid right across the range of manufacturers and are intended to help the person who asked the original question.

    Edited by HDVdiver
  5. I understand partner, it's just that Anthony is new to Wetpixel and I don't think we should expect him to know to look at your link.

     

    Have fun,

    Steve

  6. I understand partner, it's just that Anthony is new to Wetpixel and I don't think we should expect him to know to look at your link.

     

    Have fun,

    Steve

     

     

    No problem...doesn't bother me one way or the other!

     

    If it helps him evaluate all the options, thats fine with me...

     

     

    Cheers

    Edited by HDVdiver
  7. Right - let's keep the commercialism out of the forums. It's fine to have a favorite brand of lights, but NOT fine to promote and market them on the Wetpixel forums.

     

    Cheers

    James

  8. Right - let's keep the commercialism out of the forums. It's fine to have a favorite brand of lights, but NOT fine to promote and market them on the Wetpixel forums.

     

    Cheers

    James

     

     

    Absolutely...I go along with that.

     

    As long as the same applies to everybody...directly or "indirectly".

     

    Besides, as a working pro videographer I've got as much right to make comments as you do about the gear I use...as long as they are relevant to the question being asked.

    Edited by HDVdiver
  9. Hi HDV,

     

    Yes, the same rules apply to everyone - but everyone has a different approach to bypassing them ;-) We try to enforce them consistently.

     

    Your last comment is definitely worth talking about too - as we are VERY HAPPY that we have working pros here who can share their experience with new products. But a working pro is different to me than a working pro who also sells equipment. If you are going to give your "review" of a product - and you also sell it, then just let us - as the users - know that ahead of time. Look at some of the equipment reviews put out by Backscatter for a good example of how to do this right.

     

    Cheers

    James

  10. Hi HDV,

     

    Yes, the same rules apply to everyone - but everyone has a different approach to bypassing them ;-) We try to enforce them consistently.

     

    Your last comment is definitely worth talking about too - as we are VERY HAPPY that we have working pros here who can share their experience with new products. But a working pro is different to me than a working pro who also sells equipment. If you are going to give your "review" of a product - and you also sell it, then just let us - as the users - know that ahead of time. Look at some of the equipment reviews put out by Backscatter for a good example of how to do this right.

     

    Cheers

    James

     

     

    I'm probably in a unique situation in that I "wear two hats"... videographer and designer/low volume manufacturer. I'm perfectly aware of this as a fine line...and I do my best to balance it. I don't remember giving a review of anything...I listed what I consider as important points that a buyer should look for when doing their own "review" of what's out there. The only "reviews" I've done is on other equipment (cameras) I have had first hand experience with...for the benefit of other potential users.

     

    No comment on the first point...It's not my intention to embarrass anyone...Even if the "infomercials/product photos" ...quite long "reviews"... for consistently the same manufacture's products that appear in these forums, are the same promotional links/material that even now appear on the manufacturer's website. If it's accepted practice for a Wetpixel moderator...

     

    Please just be consistent!

     

    Cheers

    Edited by HDVdiver
  11. I'm biased as a retailer of underwater imaging equipment, but I'm also in the unique position to have tried almost everything out there.

     

    I think Sunray 2000x are a very good system. The "x" gets you 400 lumen more power, and significantly wider/smoother beam. These are very good lights, and can cover wide lenses like 16-35 and 15 (with careful composition). My one issue with these lights is that I can't decide on a mounting solution for using them alongside strobes.

     

    I used to own Subtronic Video 16:9, which punch out 3700 lumen. These actually metered lower than the Sunray 2000x due to their flood beam, but I haven't seen anything else this wide and soft.

     

    I just purchased a pair of the Aditech 4V4L40 4050 lumen lights, but I haven't had a chance to dive with them yet. They look really good in air, similar to the Subtronic lights in beam angle. These will likely be the lights I use on dedicated HD-DSLR video dives.

     

    Of all the self contained 1000 lumen lights, Fix LED1000DX is my favorite. The beam angle is very wide, and they are easy to mount alongside strobes for shooting both still photo and video. These are much colder than most other lights, but that hasn't proven to be a problem for me. It is actually easier to set up mixed lighting scenes than with warmer lights because the ct gap isn't too wide.

  12. Hi Ryan,

    Have you had a chance to play with the L&M Sola 600 light yet? One shot from the Long Beach show shows it side by side with the FIX and it looks a little more compact. Not sure about the specs though.

     

    Steve

  13. Have you had a chance to play with the L&M Sola 600 light yet? One shot from the Long Beach show shows it side by side with the FIX and it looks a little more compact. Not sure about the specs though.

    Steve

     

    The Sola 600, though it claims 600 lumens output is supposedly underrated. I've been told it's closer to 650 lumens. Meanwhile the FIX LED 100DX's output is 777 lumens according the this test by Backscatter. These lights were evaluated in an Integrating Sphere (wikipedia) so spatial information (diffusion, beam angle) don't interfere with the intensity measurement.

    I plan on buying three Sola 600s. Zero-maintenance and small size make this light very appealing to me. The red light is just icing.

     

    -Brad

  14. My limited experience with a pair of LED1000DX was that they were ok, albeit somewhat underwhelming. My issue was that one wouldn't turn off, then the other flooded. Given the quality issues I hit with relatively new gear I won't go near them in future.

     

    I've used a single Sunray 1000 which I quite liked; batteries would mount nicely under housing and the small heads are workable on loc-line. Two of them would be nice if they were mounted cleanly.

     

    I'm interested in the Sola 600, though as a stills modelling light. I don't think they'll have enough output for WA shooting of wrecks (I'm taking two 1000DX's as a baseline, which were barely strong enough for my purposes).

     

    Ryan, I'd love to hear how you go with the Aditech lights. If you could post some video and a report that'd be awesome.

  15. I used to own Subtronic Video 16:9, which punch out 3700 lumen. These actually metered lower than the Sunray 2000x due to their flood beam, but I haven't seen anything else this wide and soft.

     

     

    Any manufacturer's lights using the new CREE XPG emitters will natively provide a "wide and soft" beam of about 100 degrees UNDERWATER (the CREE data sheet rating is 125 degrees) since each emitter has its own "lens". In the case of multiple XPG's (without reflectors) the resultant cone of light is very even right out to the edges of the beam spread. CREE also bin their leds very accurately/conservatively in terms of luminosity and chromaticity...you actually get what their data sheets claim. Importantly, the lumen rating is for their native beam angle of 125 degrees.

     

    The other good thing about CREE leds is that the XPG's @ 350mA have a Lumen/watt efficiency of about 130 (the new XM's will boost this to 160 when available in a couple of months time).

     

    Remarkably, CREE have just broken the elusive 200-lumen-per-watt efficacy barrier for a single white power LED (208 Lumens per watt @ 5000K @ 350mA...nothing exotic...very usable for underwater videography). These will be in new lights early in 2011.

    Edited by HDVdiver
Aquatica

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.