i was feeling all helpful when i opened up this thread .. then .. and then all it got was a strikethrough !
Comon !!
Anyway .. I wouldn't worry about hurricane damage, if anything hurricanes do the reef some good I believe cooling the water down and preventing coral bleaching. The south side of the island took the worst of Ivan in 2004 but has recovered nicely since I am told (I have not gotten out south in a while) The East end is known for it's untouched beauty and Ocean frontiers are a great organisation. The West and North are not bad and offer the chance to stay on Seven Mile Beach where the apres diving is a little more interesting and accessible. restaurants and bars etc, if you sta out east you are limited.
If you wish to limit yourself further but take in a little bit of Heaven there is always Little Cayman and Bloody Bay wall ..
If you would like any specific questions answered or advice go ahead and ask them, no need to keep it in PM unless you don't want people to know what you are planning. I will answer both here and PM.