Vignetting or artistic tool?

Artistic tool or wrong extension ring?

Wrong Extension Ring,

but may be used as hardware artistic tool

Chris

Artistic tool or wrong extension ring?

 

Would be more appealing (to my eye) if the extension was set further out completing the circle. That being said it's a cool picture that can be seen as from the camera's perspective

Jose

Both, but I preffer full circle for artistic purposes.

I realized after about 4 shots that I was getting vignetting, and zoomed out.

However I realized that this image had a certain quality to it. Without the framing of the lens it would be a rather boring photo.

I am curious if others think the photo is worth saving.

Also got me thinking of what you could do with a full frame camera shooting a DX wide angle lens.

I find the baffles rather disturbing...