Skip to content

Video Gear and Technique / Archived topic

Is red filter necessary for GH3 underwater video ?

Started by edmond320 ·

  • 7Posts
  • 7Replies

Read-only discussion

Is red filter necessary for GH3 underwater video ?

7 posts
  1. I have been using Panasonic TM700 with Sealux housing for few years. While taking underwater video, using red filter and frequent manual white balance will easily bring out the colour.

    Last month , I tried filming video at Hin Daeng, using GH3 in Nauticam housing, two FIT 5000 video light, I am not sure how to regain the redness which is quite easy to achieve with the flip red filter. The colour tone of the video is just not right !!!

    Can anyone help me ? Give me the tips how to regain the redness with the GH3 in Nauticam housing ??

    Thank you very much.

     

    Regards

    Edmond

  2. What lenses/ports are you using? Can you post a sample or screenshots of the type of footage that is just not right?

  3. What lenses/ports are you using? Can you post a sample or screenshots of the type of footage that is just not right?

    This video was taken with GH3,12-35 lens,Nauticam 6' wide angle dome port, FIT 5000 video light, manual white balance.

    I think the blue is not blue enough, and the coral without the reach of the video light,the colour doesn't look great, very pale.

  4. Hi all, I had the similar washout blue/boring color situation on my LX-7 like Edmond's. Here is my thought: Is it because the sun is in front of us? I read some underwater photography book that to have the best blue (especially the use of Magic Filter), the sun should be behind us, does that apply to video?

     

    Also, if we have to shoot at the direction of the sun, would under expose deepen up the blue and have more shadow detail?

  5. What are you pointing the camera at when you white balance, and is it illuminated by your lights? Because the near stuff is so red in your clip, I guess you white balanced on something distant that is not illuminated by your lights. I think even auto or white balance could look better.

     

    For that sort of scene, unless you have huge lighting power and coverage, I think you should try shooting without the lights and use manual white balance. Because the GH3 doesn't do raw, and there is no way to flip a filter with the 6" port, you would probably get a richer-coloured result with a Magic filter or similar behind the lens. There is a filter holder for the Panasonic 8mm lens that can be fitted in the back of the 7-14mm lens. Apparently it's part number VXQ1911. I suppose that might fit behind the 12-35mm lens too, but I don't know. Of course the problem with that approach is that everything will turn red if you try and shoot something with lights under a ledge etc., and I don't know how well the GH3 can balance that back to white. It could probably do it but the quality would suffer compared to shooting with illumination and no filter.

     

    So really you have to make a choice before the dive whether to shoot lights or filter. This is one of the big downsides of a rig with no flippable filter.

     

    The more distant "pale" footage, beyond the reach of your lights, could be improved a lot in post-production by increasing contrast, boosting red etc..

     

    kc_moses Most stuff looks better with the sun behind the shooter. But there is some more fundamental problem with these washed out colours than just that.

     

    p.s. I've never had a GH3 or anything remotely like it. I'm thinking of getting one but primarily as a macro rig that I expect not to be the best solution for wide angle.

  6. Hi Nick,

    Thank you very much for your professional advice.

    I just have my Ninja 2 nauticam housing and I am sure it help post adjustment of the footage from GH3.

    But honestly, I am not happy to film video without the flip red filter which I found so easy to compensate the red colour while filming, no need to wait for post adjustment.

    Regarding the white balance targeting, I need more practice with the new rig, hope I can do better later.

  7. I don't think the Ninja 2 will significantly help with post adjustment of colours. The GH3 only outputs 8-bit 4:2:0 over HDMI, and the camera's internal codec is already All-I and a high bitrate (72mbps). Here's a blog on it. Also I understand the Ninja

    . But I suppose it's nice to have a backup to the internal recording, or to maybe save the money over shooting on cards. And of course the monitoring features are a bonus.

     

    I am interested in how the Ninja 2 (in Nauticam housing) compares to the SmallHD DP4 (in Nauticam housing), purely for monitoring. I'll start a new thread on that.

    Edited by Nick Hope
Retra

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.