Skip to content

Photography Gear and Technique / Archived topic

moving to 17-40mm from 17-85, good move?

Started by emptech ·

  • 4Posts
  • 4Replies

Read-only discussion

moving to 17-40mm from 17-85, good move?

4 posts
  1. Currently I have a Canon 30D with a 17-85mm and a +4 diopter in an Ikelite housing, 6" dome port. I want to upgrade to a 7D (which I already have) and upgrade the lens. I don't want to use a diopter lens, so need to choose something that will focus to less than 12". I'm considering a Canon 17-40mm and a 6" dome.

     

    I have Ikelite DS125 and DS160 strobes, so I should have plenty of light.

     

    Next part, more of a comment, since I will now have the ability to shoot video, I plan on mounting my two L&M SOLA 2000 video lights to my strobes, will look a little funny but will give me both options, I'm giving up using a seperate video camera.

     

     

    Is anybody else using the 17-40mm lens, and if so, any comments or suggestions? I would like the 16-35mm but I need to cut some costs.

     

    Jim

  2. I have that lens for land use, and don't really like it. Plus you will need a bigger dome than 6 inches. I think you will be much happier with the Tokina 10-17mm, and a 60mm macro. I use mine for video and stills with my 70D. There is no one lens that does it all, at least well.. I use the solas and strobes with a 3 way clamp. Kind of awkward, but it works.

     

    Hal

  3. I ended up going with the Canon 17-40 L lens. I purchased a 6" dome, and have been very happy with it. The reason I left the 17-85mm is that it had to use a +4 diopter, which eliminated any above water shots. The only negative thing with the 17-40 is I wish it was longer than 40mm, for small targets I have to do a lot of cropping. Now that I've used the 17-40 for a couple years, I'm going to try a Sigma 17-70mm, but it will require an 8" dome. The lens is on order and will order the dome soon.

     

    Reviews say the 17-70 isn't a good wide angle nor a good macro, but I think it will give me a little more reach. I'm also thinking of a macro, 60mm or 100mm soon.

     

    Jim

  4. I received the brand new, latest version of the Sigma 17-70mm F2.8-4 DC Macro OS HSM lens. According to Ikelite's lens chooser, this lens will not work because the diameter of the barrel is too large, although there are work-arounds. The new lens has a barrel diameter of 2.825" and an extended length of 4.860". It works fine with their #0073 zoom sleeve kit. With an 8" dome, it will require an extension a little longer than what Ikelite recommended for the original 17-70mm. I believe their 8" kit 5511.5 will do the trick, just confirming with Ikelite.

     

    Looks like I hijacked my own thread ...

     

    Jim

WaterPixels Store

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.