Anyone have any good lightroom / photoshop methods for post processing out silt and noise? I've been experimenting with some darker, siltier environments lately, and can't find a way to manage what silt does end up in the photo effectively.
Shooting Technique, Workflow and Editing / Archived topic
Post processing for silt and noise
Started by jreilly2120 ·
- 13Posts
- 13Replies
Read-only discussion
Post processing for silt and noise
-
-
I always select the region with the noise and use the "remove dust and scratches" too soften the noise.

-
That actually looks like it works pretty well. I have been individually selecting the silt particles. I think I'll try that. Thanks!
-
That's a Photoshop option, not a Lightroom option. I'd pay a good bit for a LR plugin that removes backscatter....I always select the region with the noise and use the "remove dust and scratches" too soften the noise.

-
You could pay 9.99 a month for PS & LR CC...and to be fair, the OP did specify LR & PS in the question.
-
I
You could pay 9.99 a month for PS & LR CC...and to be fair, the OP did specify LR & PS in the question.
I'd like to avoid the learning curve of PS.
I consider plug-ins as part of the LR/PS system, so to be clearer I'd like a plug-in for LR.
-
The learning curve is not bad. Id just bite the bullet and do it now. Back on topic, I'm going to give this a shot this weekend. Silty test pictures incoming.
-
JReilly
Doug Sloss in his "Underwater Photoworkshop" DVD presented a nice Photoshop technique to remove a lot of backscatter from an image if you can afford to loose detail in the background. I don't know if it is still on his "Adobe Photoshop CS4 for the Underwater Photographer" DVD http://www.underwaterphotoshop.com/. Erin Quigley present a very similar (if not the same) technique at http://www.scubadiving.com/photoshop-tutorial-how-to-remove-backscatter-from-underwater-photos
-
JReilly
Doug Sloss in his "Underwater Photoworkshop" DVD presented a nice Photoshop technique to remove a lot of backscatter from an image if you can afford to loose detail in the background. I don't know if it is still on his "Adobe Photoshop CS4 for the Underwater Photographer" DVD http://www.underwaterphotoshop.com/. Erin Quigley present a very similar (if not the same) technique at http://www.scubadiving.com/photoshop-tutorial-how-to-remove-backscatter-from-underwater-photos
I was told Quigley invented the technique, although in his article he says he got it from Eddie Tapp.
-
I find the healing tool with content aware selected in photoshop is a great way of getting rid of individual spots and un-wanted particles. Even removing and replacing distracting background areas or objects! The clone/healing tool in LR is also extremely useful but a lot slower and less accurate i find personally.
-
As a Lightroom plug in, you could install the Nik Collection from Google. The noise reduction plug in can help soften the Backscatter.
I change from "automatic" to "manual" and then select a background area with Backscatter.
-
Here's the link to the Nik Collection (it is now free!):
https://www.google.com/nikcollection/
And the noise reduction one is called "Dfine."
-
Thanks! I think that's definitely worth a shot