Skip to content

Video Gear and Technique / Archived topic

1/125 for 30p instead of 1/60? (AX100/GATES)

Started by wydeangle ·

  • 4Posts
  • 4Replies

Read-only discussion

1/125 for 30p instead of 1/60? (AX100/GATES)

4 posts
  1. We were diving Bonaire the last two weeks. While there, I asked John Wall of the Buddy Dive Photo Center if he had any recommendations for settings for underwater video. I use 4K/30p video exclusively.

     

    He surprised me by suggesting 1/125 shutter speed instead of the 1/60 I had been using.

     

    The purpose, he said, was to reduce motion blur for moving subjects.

     

    I wondered if that would reduce the light enough to cause problems, but the result with my AX100/Gates setup has been truly better in my amateur eyes. And not just a little bit - a lot!

     

    Underwater video came out much better. I went back to using auto WB, auto GAIN/ISO and auto IRIS (F-stop), locking shutter speed at 1/125 and got some of the best video so far with that setup.

     

    I tried it topside on flamingos and other subjects and was also well pleased.

     

    I said to John well, if some's good more must be better, right? He said no, that if you increase the shutter speed beyond 1/125 you begin to get a "cathedral effect" where vertical light streaks appear in the video. I did observe this in shallow water at 1/125 when the top part of the scene was brightly lit, but the bottom area was darker.

     

    There were a few circumstances where the visibility was poor that were not very good. Not sure how 1/60 would have done there as it was contrast that suffered. The camera still seemed to autofocus OK.

     

    1/125 has now become my standard setting - I'm sure I will deviate back to 1/60 if circumstances require it.

     

    This was news to me - I'd been using 1/60 for a couple of years.

     

    Any comments or other advice?

     

    Tom

  2. Interesting! Can you post some video footage?

  3. ya, I'd be intersted as well. I am in 50hz territory, and I do sometimes shoot with shutter 100 instead of 50. But cant say that this looks substantially better...

    Edited by bubffm
  4. Sorry 'bout that! It has taken a while to find two clips that illustrate the difference in sharpness that were (sort of) comparable in light level and included motion.

     

    The first clip (Slender Filefish) was taken at 1/60 and the second (Turtle head) at 1/125. I just included a still capture from each because the difference to me is the same as seen in the clip. Here they are:

    post-18574-0-56939700-1498323179_thumb.jpg

     

    post-18574-0-66897400-1498323602_thumb.jpg

     

    I had to reduce the image sizes to upload the files, trying to preserve the level of detail; these are close, but the IQ of each did suffer in the reduction of file size.

     

    I hope the IQ carries through enough to let you see the difference.

     

    Tom

    Edited by wydeangle
Turtle

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.