Skip to content

Lights, Strobes, and Lighting Technique / Archived topic

Any users of turtle manual flash trigger?

Started by Interceptor121 ·

  • 17Posts
  • 17Replies

Read-only discussion

Any users of turtle manual flash trigger?

17 posts
  1. I am looking for a trigger for my A1. The nauticam one does not support rear flash sync which is a surprise to me so am looking at options

    I am not interested in TTL triggers I am ok with manual but there are not many manual options around so I have seen this one

    I wonder if anyone has used it and has experience even outside Sony products?

  2. I have one and i use it on a panasonic gx9 and nauticam housing. Mainly used in manual and hss synch to retra flash.

    Very happy with it (!) but not sure about rear synch.

    Andrea

    Inviato dal mio SM-A325F utilizzando Tapatalk

  3. 2 hours ago, Interceptor121 said:

    I am looking for a trigger for my A1. The nauticam one does not support rear flash sync which is a surprise to me so am looking at options

    I am not interested in TTL triggers I am ok with manual but there are not many manual options around so I have seen this one

    I wonder if anyone has used it and has experience even outside Sony products?

    To support rear curtain sync the trigger needs to imitate a flash in the hotshoe so the camera thinks it can communicate with it, only then does the flash control menu activate which allow you to switch to rear curtain sync.  Manual only triggers work by just hooking up the centre and ground pins and the camera completes that circuit on every exposure allowing for example studio type flashes to be triggered - or in our case a manual flash trigger to activate. 

    It looks like the manual turtle trigger imitates a Sony flash so the camera can set rear curtain sync but doesn't include the TTL circuitry going by the description, so it's one step up from a basic dumb manual trigger. 

    Rear curtain sync is only a change in timing for the flash so if the camera would allow you turn on rear curtain sync without a flash attached an ordinary manual trigger might work?  It would depend on how the rear curtain sync is actually triggered.

  4. To support rear curtain sync the trigger needs to imitate a flash in the hotshoe so the camera thinks it can communicate with it, only then does the flash control menu activate which allow you to switch to rear curtain sync.  Manual only triggers work by just hooking up the centre and ground pins and the camera completes that circuit on every exposure allowing for example studio type flashes to be triggered - or in our case a manual flash trigger to activate. 
    It looks like the manual turtle trigger imitates a Sony flash so the camera can set rear curtain sync but doesn't include the TTL circuitry going by the description, so it's one step up from a basic dumb manual trigger. 
    Rear curtain sync is only a change in timing for the flash so if the camera would allow you turn on rear curtain sync without a flash attached an ordinary manual trigger might work?  It would depend on how the rear curtain sync is actually triggered.

    Hence the question
    Now other users are telling me the Nauticam does it too


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  5. I use the UW Tecnics trigger in manual mode with my A7 RIV and Retra strobes. Works great. I haven't explicitly tested Rear Curtain Sync. 

    - brett

  6. On 1/7/2023 at 1:45 PM, Interceptor121 said:


    Hence the question
    Now other users are telling me the Nauticam does it too


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

    Regarding Nauticam flash triggers, it may depend on the camera brand. For the manual Sony trigger, Nauticam states explicitely that rear curtain is not working: https://www.nauticam.com/products/mini-flash-trigger-for-sony-compatible-with-na-a7-a7ii-a9

    => Are you sure the users talked about Sony flash trigger?

     

    There is an old tread about experience with turtle triggers (TTL version, but should be similar):

    View archived post in: Experience with TRT S-Turtle TTL trigger?

     

    Wolfgang

     

    P.S.: for how many dives does a single charging up of turtle trigger last?

     

     

     

    Edited by Architeuthis
  7. Just now, Architeuthis said:

    Regarding Nauticam flash triggers, it may depend on the camera brand. For the manual Sony trigger, Nauticam states explicitely that rear curtain is not working: https://www.nauticam.com/products/mini-flash-trigger-for-sony-compatible-with-na-a7-a7ii-a9

    => Are you sure the users talked about Sony flash trigger?

     

    There is an old tread about experience with turtle triggers (TTL version, but should be similar):

    View archived post in: Experience with TRT S-Turtle TTL trigger?

     

    Wolfgang

     

     

     

    Interestingly another Sony A1 user has confirmed the nauticam trigger does work with rear curtain... so the case is closed

  8. I have reviews for TRT S-turtle and UWTechnics in uwpmag.com. Both are with TTL units because that is what they sent me and because TTL is not offered widely in fiber optic flash triggers. I have also used versions for other camera brands, the Nauticam manual triggers for a verity of camera brands both in manual and TTL along with the Marelux manual triggers. 

    Each has strengths and weaknesses. First some are installed in the housing like the UWTech, Marelux and others while the S-turtle and Nauticam are more easily removed from the housing. S-turtle requires that you use a mini-USB to charge an internal battery. I did not find the charge lasted near as long as the button batteries (most use two) for in the other brands. With Nauticam and S-turtle the trigger needs to be turned on and off while the housing is open. With UWTech and Marelux when the camera is turned on the trigger is on and off when turned off. The Nauticam is a more sealed unit that is less likely to get wet when the housing is opened followed by S-Turtle. Some require that you use a program in the computer to change settings. Others allow you to change settings like HSS on the trigger. 

    Regardless of which I trigger I use I never travel outside my area without a backup. In some cases I have carried a spare bulkhead and wired split cord for my Inon flashes to replace fiber optic cords which works with rear curtain. 

  9. I have reviews for TRT S-turtle and UWTechnics in uwpmag.com. Both are with TTL units because that is what they sent me and because TTL is not offered widely in fiber optic flash triggers. I have also used versions for other camera brands, the Nauticam manual triggers for a verity of camera brands both in manual and TTL along with the Marelux manual triggers. 
    Each has strengths and weaknesses. First some are installed in the housing like the UWTech, Marelux and others while the S-turtle and Nauticam are more easily removed from the housing. S-turtle requires that you use a mini-USB to charge an internal battery. I did not find the charge lasted near as long as the button batteries (most use two) for in the other brands. With Nauticam and S-turtle the trigger needs to be turned on and off while the housing is open. With UWTech and Marelux when the camera is turned on the trigger is on and off when turned off. The Nauticam is a more sealed unit that is less likely to get wet when the housing is opened followed by S-Turtle. Some require that you use a program in the computer to change settings. Others allow you to change settings like HSS on the trigger. 
    Regardless of which I trigger I use I never travel outside my area without a backup. In some cases I have carried a spare bulkhead and wired split cord for my Inon flashes to replace fiber optic cords which works with rear curtain. 

    Thanks Phil will download the back issues
    Does any of those support burst shooting?


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  10. For me a reasonable burst is around 5/6 FPS. My Z-330 strobes can keep up that rate at lower powers. All of the flash triggers I reviewed can flash that quickly. The Olympus on camera flash for manual/TTL with fiber was horrible.

  11. For me a reasonable burst is around 5/6 FPS. My Z-330 strobes can keep up that rate at lower powers. All of the flash triggers I reviewed can flash that quickly. The Olympus on camera flash for manual/TTL with fiber was horrible.

    Brilliant
    Did you review the Nauticam? Am not sure that supports burst but is very rugged and currently my preference


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  12. I have used the Nauticam trigger the most and yes it can do multi flash the same as the rest.

  13. I have used the Nauticam trigger the most and yes it can do multi flash the same as the rest.

    Thank you that closes the case!


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  14. 9 hours ago, Interceptor121 said:

    Interestingly another Sony A1 user has confirmed the nauticam trigger does work with rear curtain... so the case is closed

    This is because the availability of rear curtain sync is an related to the camera body and the way it is implemented I would think.  It will vary from camera to camera.

  15. 12 hours ago, ChrisRoss said:

    This is because the availability of rear curtain sync is an related to the camera body and the way it is implemented I would think.  It will vary from camera to camera.

    I have a TTL and manual flash for the A1

    Interesting behaviour

    Manual flash only works with mechanical shutter but supports first, rear curtain HSS and burst

    TTL flash supports first, rear, hss and burst in both electronic and mechanical shutter but it will limit the shutter speed until you press HSS

    I have been in touch with TR electronics and is quite difficult to understand what is going to happen between the ttl and manual version

  16. what do you mean by press HSS?

    Edited by insomniac — misread post
  17. what do you mean by press HSS?

    Set wireless flash inside the camera puts hss on normally


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
WaterPixels Store

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.