Underwater Camera Systems: A Comparative (in the Field) Performance Review This was a weekend project, and it surely has some flaws and biases. Just giving our perspective on what we saw with these results. Objective: Evaluate and compare three underwater video systems RED Helium (7K RAW, 60 fps, Log; ISO 800; Canon 16–35 mm) Canon R5 Mark II (4K sRAW, 60 fps, Log 2; ISO 800; Canon 10–20 mm) Canon 1D X Mark II (4K Fine, 60 fps; ISO 800; Canon 24-70 mm) all housed in Nauticam, with post production in DaVinci Resolve 20. Locations & Conditions • La Reina (Cerralvo Island, Mexico): Depth 2-5 m; visibility 25 m; open ocean blue; strong sunlight; friendly giant manta. • El Vencedor (Cabo Pulmo, Mexico): Depth 14 m; visibility 10 m; turbid, greenish blue; high activity (8+ bull sharks). Methodology 1. Standard Settings: All systems at ISO 800, auto (or custom) white balance, Log profiles (except Canon 1D X without Log). Focal length varied per dive. 2. Shot Pairing: Captured simultaneous or near simultaneous clips from two systems per scene; matched framing, distance, angle, and light as closely as possible. 3. Post Processing: DaVinci Resolve 20; primary correction (balance, contrast), secondary grading (hue/saturation), spatial denoise as needed. Test Sequences 1. Giant Manta (Surface): Canon R5 II, RED: https://vimeo.com/1102366224 2. Manta + Diver: RED, Canon R5 II: https://vimeo.com/1102366387 3. Bullsharks: RED, Canon R5 II, Canon 1DX MII: https://vimeo.com/1102366448 Metrics & Rankings (for us) 1. Dynamic Range 1st: RED Helium — Exceptional latitude in harsh shadows/highlights; range ≈16 stops. 2nd: Canon R5 II — Robust performance in direct sunlight; range ≈14 stops. 3rd: Canon 1D X II — Limited by Rec.709 gamut; range ≈11 stops. 2. Sharpness (300 % zoom) 1st: RED Helium — Highest resolving power; artifacts negligible at 4K output. 2nd: Canon R5 II — Slightly softer than RED; no perceptible difference at normal viewing distances at 4K output. 3rd: Canon 1D X II — Lowest micro detail; adequate for 4K playback. 3.Color Science 1st: Canon R5 II — Accurate warm tone recovery with custom WB; maximum color grading latitude 2nd: Canon 1D X II — Natural skin tone palette; log less workflow simplified but limited latitude. 3rd: RED Helium — Neutral baseline; struggled with warm hues in turbid water; requires masking or advanced secondary curves especially in deeper dives. 4 .Noise 1st: RED Helium — Cleanest under low light; minimal spatial denoise applied. 2nd: Canon 1D X II — Moderate noise; less than R5 II in underexposed areas. 3rd: Canon R5 II — Most noise at base ISO 800; resolved via spatial denoise, recommended exposure +1 stop. 5. Ergonomics & Cost 1st: Canon 1D X II — Mid-weight/affordable (used market ~$5-7KUSD); ideal entry level. 2nd: Canon R5 II — Most compact; moderate cost ($~12KUSD); superior stabilization. 3rd: RED Helium — Highest cost (~$45K USD) and bulk; professional grade stabilization. Conclusions •RED Helium: Choose for maximal dynamic range and detail (e.g., commercial cinematography). Budget and weight are significant factors. Color grading will have to be taken care by a profesional. •Canon R5 II: Best balance of image quality, color fidelity, and handling. Recommended for independent filmmakers and enthusiasts. •Canon 1D X II: Cost effective entry to 4K underwater; ideal for novices or secondary camera. After all those dives and countless shots from this weekend, it really comes down to being in the right place at the right time. No matter which camera you choose, if you’re closer, steady, and nail your angle and exposure, you’ll walk away with an amazing image. It’s recommended to prioritize positioning, timing, and stability—these elements often contribute more to a standout underwater image than the choice of camera, especially when viewing on a 4K display. Technical Note: Camera and codec choice is usually dictated by the SVOD or broadcaster, based on how well the camera’s image pipeline and recording format hold up under their platform’s compression. It’s not just about the look of the footage on set—it’s about how it survives multiple layers of encoding and streaming at lower bitrates. Platforms like Netflix, Apple TV+, and Disney+ often require primary cameras to capture at least 4K RAW or 10-bit 4:2:2 (RED Helium and R5 Mark II both have these codecs) with wide dynamic range and robust color depth, and favour intra-frame codecs (ProRes, XOCN, REDCODE) over Long GOP or 8‑bit 4:2:0. Ultimately, technical approval depends less on aesthetic appeal and more on how reliably an image holds up across global delivery systems.
Many thanks!!
