Skip to content

Lights, Strobes, and Lighting Technique / Archived topic

Choices: DS-50 or YS15-Auto for Canon s50?

Started by Scubaskeeter ·

  • 9Posts
  • 9Replies

Read-only discussion

Choices: DS-50 or YS15-Auto for Canon s50?

9 posts
  1. I have a Canon s50, been using the internal strobe for 2 years with increasingly good results, but that "time" has come. I want an external strobe. Looks like the YS15 has an "auto" feature that appeals to me, using slave. But does it only works on f2.8?

     

    The DS50 has more batteries and shorter recycle time, and I like that because lately, I'm after angels and other reef fish. It claims to have a cable-free slave which sounds good too but not sure if it's as "auto" as the YS15. The arm looks better for this one.

     

    It's bewildering, with all the choices out there, but WetPixel definitely helped me narrow it down to these two. Comments appreciated, on these two, unless of course one of you has a better suggestion!

     

    Thanks!

    Edited by Scubaskeeter
  2. You can also add the Inon D-2000 or newer models which also incorporate an "Auto" mode, and have similar features to what you're after.

     

    Now, that didn't make your choice any easier, did it? :D:P

  3. The Canon S50 features an TTL based flash metering system. With some solutions you could make use of this with an external strobe as well.

     

    The ys-15 has its own build-in light metering sensor. The strobe decides how much light your camera needs. As you have said, the strobe always assumes your camera’s aperture is set to f2.8. I think this strobe is designed for those little ixus-style point and shoot cameras that doesn’t allow any aperture setting but fit nicely into girl’s handbags. Those cameras switch automatically to f2.8 if there is not much ambient light, no matter if you wish to flash the frame. But you have a camera that allows you to choose the aperture and ISO value. So I won’t buy a strobe that limits your camera to f2.8 as the strobe doesn’t even seem to have manual power settings to override this hassle.

     

    The ys-15 has a topside guide number of 12. It doesn’t seem to be much more powerful than the internal strobe in terms of brightness. Just a somewhat increased coverage and a further away position from the camera.

     

    If you trigger an external strobe without optical cable, the internal strobe will light still light the backscatter in front of the lens because the internal strobe is used to trigger the external one. Don't know about certain solutions (blocking options for the internal strobe, etc.), but I would make sure the internal strobe doesn't light the scene anymore.

     

    Julian

  4. Thanks Jolly, I did notice that the YS15 did not state the watt-secs of power on the spec page!

     

    Maybe I'll start looking at a higher number, 90 or 125!

  5. I'm also looking at the possibility of adding an Inon D-2000 to my Canon S50 setup, which is a WP-DC300 housing and a Sea&Sea Motormarine 16mm wide angle lens.

     

    Has anyone used the Inon Clear Photo System with this setup?

    Sample underwater photos would be great :P

  6. Andy, what you Jolly and Matt are saying is starting to sink in to my brain. Why start small? When I buy a computer, it's for the next few years so it makes sense to buy a strobe compatible with a future purchase of u/w DSLR. One can power down to fit the smaller camera, no?

     

    I'm now considering the higher numbers YS90, D-2000 or Ike 125. I presume these will work well with a Canon Rebel XT and 18-55 lens. Will I need more strobe power for a zoom lens like a 105mm?

    Edited by Scubaskeeter
  7. ............I'm now considering the higher numbers YS90, D-2000 or Ike 125.........

     

    Those "higher" numbers found in the names of strobes by various manufacturers do not help the consumer much for comparative purposes, especially across manufacturers lines.

     

    The "90" in YS 90 appears to be quite arbitrary. No specifications supplied by Sea & Sea equals the number 90.

     

    I believe Inon multiplies the top side guide number rating of the D-2000 (GN20, ISO 100, metric) by 100 to arrive at it's name. Previously Inon would only multiply by 10 the metric guide number (D-180, Z-220, for instance).

     

    Ikelite traditionally names its strobes after their watt-second rating. The exception to the "rule" is the DS 125. I believe 125 watt-seconds may have been the target, but 110 watt seconds is what is found in the Ikelite specs. That said, the DS-50, 100, 200, etc all held true to the name formula.

     

    Epoque appears to multiply the topside GN (metric) by 10 to arrive at their strobe names.

     

    Hartenberger and Seacam in the past have utilized watt second nameplates. Subtronic names, sometimes Greek, sometimes referring to size comparisons within the line such as mini, mega, etc, do not necessarily pinpoint to any concrete user information.

  8. With all the sales restistance of a shopaholic, I've made my decision with the expert help at WetPixel and Ike! I'm going with the DS125 & s50 combo then eventually move it to a RebXT/Ike with the synch cable. That will give me small redundance on a dive trip with the s50, if the Rebel f***ds. Thanks everyone, I really appreciate all the comments.

    >

    >Please tell me what I need for the s50 then what additional stuff I need for the RebXT. >I want deluxe arms, tray, everything for both.

    >Can't I use pkg #3944.77 for the s50 (with add'l handle/tray) then use that

    >same pkg. (with the #4103.51 sync cord) for the RebXT w u/w Ike case?

     

    Yes, you can do that

     

    >

    >Can I or even should I use the #4100.5 TTL Slave Sensor with s50/Canon u/w

    >case?

     

    Does the s50 case have a Ikelite connection for sync cord? If no need #4110.6.

Keldan

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.