Skip to content

Photography Gear and Technique / Archived topic

1DmkII or 5D

Started by james ·

  • 54Posts
  • 54Replies

Read-only discussion

1DmkII or 5D

54 posts
  1. Hi Guys,

     

    Yes, I have DEPP, but I only insured my camera and lenses, not the housing. DEPP is very good about replacing gear. I also have a Homeowner's replacement policy for the stuff that was stolen out of my house, but it's much more confusing. They will initially give me a check based on the depreciated value of the stuff stolen. Then, I can go out and buy replacement items. If the items turn out to be more than the depreciated value they paid me to begin with, I get a check for the difference. Thank goodness!!! This is only because I have a special endorsement on my policy (called a 1205 w/ Allstate).

     

    So, I talked to DEPP and I found out that lo and behold, they have modernized a bit, and they do "upgrade" coverage now. For example, rather than them buying me another 20D to replace the one that was stolen, I can send them $1500 and they will send me a 5D instead. This is new information for me and very good news. Used to be that they would just send you a replacement and that's it.

     

    Cheers

    James

    Edited by james
  2. Hi James,

     

    If it were me, I would keep what I got and get the 1DsII. You might save the $4500 up front going with the 5D but buying any Seacam housing is in my opinon a long term purchase. You already have a backup in the 1DII which is perfect for shooting topside. The image quality on the 1DsII should be good enough to get the most out of your housing for it's life. Also with any luck, Canon will not change the physical size/controls of the sucessor to the 1DsII and your housing will then be an even better value, lasting much longer. Also in your particular situation, you can get the Seacam housing now for the Mark II and be shooting again in short order.

     

    These are the reasons why I went with the 1DII, 1DsII and Seacam combo. It cost two arms and a leg but I know I have a system that I can live with for the long run and for me, get my monies worth out of it. None of this is to knock the 5D but without the weather sealing and focus advantage the Mark II's have and the unknown upgrade path for it's sucsessor to fit in a 5D housing, the Mark II path seems a good one.

     

    Keith

  3. Also with any luck, Canon will not change the physical size/controls of the sucessor to the 1DsII and your housing will then be an even better value, lasting much longer.

     

    For the sake of UW photographers, I hope that you are right, Keith. But my feeling is that this will change. There has been little to criticise about 1D series. The only criticism that comes up regularly is ergonomics. And I think Canon will redress this in the next upgrade. Plus I think they will put a big screen on the back, which will change the positions of all the buttons etc.

     

    Anyway we might find out at PMA?

     

    Alex

  4. For the sake of UW photographers, I hope that you are right, Keith. But my feeling is that this will change. There has been little to criticise about 1D series. The only criticism that comes up regularly is ergonomics. And I think Canon will redress this in the next upgrade. Plus I think they will put a big screen on the back, which will change the positions of all the buttons etc.

     

    If it were only enlarging the screen, they wouldn't necessarily need to modify the body; the IDMkII "N" has a larger screen, yet seems to have kept all the buttons in the same place. OTOH, I think you're right -- they'll do more than JUST enlarge the screen, including finally switching from NiMH to Lithium Ion battery, which I doubt would be exactly the same size and shape as the current batteries. They'll probably try to shrink and lighten the body at least a little to make it easier to handle (above water)...

  5. If it were only enlarging the screen, they wouldn't necessarily need to modify the body; the IDMkII "N" has a larger screen, yet seems to have kept all the buttons in the same place.  OTOH, I think you're right -- they'll do more than JUST enlarge the screen, including finally switching from NiMH to Lithium Ion battery, which I doubt would be exactly the same size and shape as the current batteries.  They'll probably try to shrink and lighten the body at least a little to make it easier to handle (above water)...

     

    Sorry to get off topic a little, but when Canon does update the 1 series body, certainly a lighter/smaller battery, body and revamped menu system is high on most users improvement wish list. I would imagine though that a 1DsIIn would be next, retaining button locations and larger screen.

     

    Keith

  6. Hi Guys,

     

    Thanks for the additional feedback. I've been thinking about the two options a bit and weighing the costs and benefit. I'll probably need to see what my insurance company is going to offer me.

     

    In the meantime, check out this cost list for the two options:

     

    2x Canon 5D's = $6,000

    Seacam 5D w/ Superdome = GUESS $6,200

    Total: $12,200

     

    Canon 1DsmkII: $7,150 (reasonable retail price)

    Canon 1DmkII: $3,500

    Seacam 1DmkII Housing w/ Superdome = $7,200

    Total: $17,850

    Total considering I already own the 1DmkII: $14,350

     

    OK, so the totals are pretty close when you consider that I've already got one of the cameras. But let's not forget Sarah - I need to replace her 20D also - which is another $1,500.

     

    These are astronomical numbers, and I'm not a professional photographer. Just adding it all up scares the $^&& out of me.

     

    James

  7. These are astronomical numbers, and I'm not a professional photographer.  Just adding it all up scares the $^&& out of me.

     

    James

     

    That is scary when you look at it that way, now stop it! :angry:

     

    Another way to look at it would be lets say you are into water skiing/wake boarding you are still at less than 1/2 of what that sport would set you back just for a decent boat! The point here (I always look at the glass half full) is that there are plenty of other non-work related activities that are just as pricey or more so...

     

    I hope your insurance kicks in and makes your decesion easier...

     

    Keith

  8. James,

     

    As Keith states those are some scary numbers for a "hobby" :angry: But many hobbyists spend the same on various other endeavors....

     

    Adding all that up your highest expense after camera bodies is the Seacam housing replacement, which makes sense if you still have ports, etc. Based on your surface shots of oil rigs which should be saleable in your neck of the oil industry, I still think the costs might be reasonable.

     

    I DO think you could do everything you're currently doing photo wise with the Canon 5D and lighten your load a bit. Plus have a "newer" body style which will likely be in demand on the used market, too.

     

    Shoot what you like as often as possible as trying to build the perfect "kit" is wasting valuable diving, shooting and editing time.....

     

    YMMV

     

    dhaas

  9. If it helps James, thats more money than all my articles and published photos combined!!!

     

    Get a D70s!!

     

    :angry:

  10. Get a point and shoot, and buy another house, man :angry::lol::P

    Edited by Kelpfish
  11. James wow much money

     

    But it depens. how much money you have :-) and how serious you take your uw photo.

     

    I mean on the end the are many OLDBOYS as we there out that have expensive toys without to need them...

     

    I have many friends that have give a left arm to buy a luxuscar that they use to drive to the weekends and if i say that my nikon d70s with housing etc. cost that amount off money they call me crazy...

     

    Maybe is one altenative more. to wait... I mean very very soon is canon comming out with a succesor of D20.. we dont know what it will be but maybe it will be intresting, if not for you maybe for Sarah (and you can use it for time to time :-)

     

    Anyway if you whant it buy it. You are a good photogpapher , bertter that some Pros. Just buy a camra that you need...

     

    I think Canon 5D will drop in the summertime so maybe you can weait for the second housing

     

    Lambis

  12. James .. my 2 cent ... the 1d series can't be beat .. the 5d is nice ... BUT if you can afford the 1d and this insurance deal gives you a reason to do so .. the there is no question .. the 5d will be replaced more often and probably sooner than the 1d series will have any major changes.

     

    I know all of us in the UW world may want smaller and lighter .. but land based pro's aren't that concerned about it .. especially the ones i know who are very much travelling land photo guys and girls ...

     

    I personally would get a 1d mkII over a 1ds mkII even though you already have one .. i just think they are a better camera . the full frame thing doesn't do it for me.

  13. Hey James,

     

    Do you really need a back up camera? That would reduce your bill a great deal. As you say you are not a pro, so while it would be disappointing if a camera went wrong on a trip, it wouldn't be the end of the world.

     

    Alex

  14. Knock on wood - I haven't had a camera go bad on a trip yet, but I do believe that a system is not complete without a backup camera. It certainly keeps my mind at ease when I travel!!! If the cost of a backup is prohibitive, I'd go for a less expensive model.

     

    A topside camera is essential for me, and it just makes sense to have the same body for backup purposes. Are there Canon film bodies with the same layout as the 1D?

  15. I had a D100 die on me in Lembeh on day 8 of 15. If I didn't have a backup, my photo trip would have been over. It is an issue of balancing your money with gear and lifestyle, but ever since I got into diving, especially for science, redundancy is essential. There have been MANY times where redundancy has saved my ass, from regulator failures, to cameras failures. In my opinion, you should budget in redundancy if you can swing it because then you have to add in those times when you $10,000 trip is cut short. Now that makes for a really expensive camera setup. :angry::lol:

     

    Joe

  16. Hi guys,

     

    I agree that redundancy is important. That's why it makes sense for Sarah and I to both shoot the 5D. We can get a total of two 5D's and another compact setup to use as a backup. If we go w/ one Seacam setup and one Ikelite or Aquatica setup then I already have the ports I need. Plus, it will be nice to have both of us shooting a FF setup and not have to worry about lenses for cropped sensor cameras.

     

    For trips that I'm on by myself, I can bring both of the 5D's. For trips that we're on together, whoever floods their 5D has to use the compact...:-)

     

    Cheers

    James

    Edited by james
  17. James,

     

    Don't you mean if you flood your housing Sarah gives hers up to you, and if she floods her housing, she gets the inexpensive backup? :angry:

  18. Joe, absolutely not, no, never. Do you think I'd say something like that on a public forum!?!?

     

    James

    Edited by james
  19. James, I know the dilemma you are going through. Canon’s 1D mk series digitals (both the 8.2 and 16) really deliver the goods, but so does their new 5D, which I have to say is nice camera. Seacam’s housing is (although a little heavy) a beautiful match with the 1D’s.

     

    I am not sure of your urgency for a replacement. Right now, I am waiting on delivery of Subal’s housing for the 5D, which, hopefully will be in before the end of this month. Knowing Seacam, delivery time for their new housing in the states will likely be some time in late April or May.

  20. You want matching cameras? Go with the 5D.

     

    Size, travel etc etc. Especially now with all the airline baggage bullshit.

     

    You don't need the 1Ds series to take a great pic.

     

    Don't let the penis envy crap get in the way. I shoot a D70 and get many pictures published and make money at it.

     

    For me, the 5D size is way better than the D2X or Mark series stuff for travel which is mostly what you do.

     

    Remember Jim Watt, Tim Rock, and I believe Doug Perrine all shoot 20D underwater

     

    Walt (another big selling photog) just said 5D.

     

    Sorry, but the diff in the two to me is a penis envy thing....

     

    Go with the 5D

    Edited by MikeVeitch
Fotosub Shop

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.