Skip to content

Photography Gear and Technique / Archived topic

Canon 60mm + Extension Tube EF 12 II or EF 25 II

Started by Paul Kay ·

  • 11Posts
  • 11Replies

Read-only discussion

Canon 60mm + Extension Tube EF 12 II or EF 25 II

11 posts
  1. I posted a query on robgalbraith.comas to whether this combination is actually viable (to find out if anyone had indeed tried it out and come to some helpful conclusion. To my surprise (and delight) I had the reply below:

     

    Hi Paul:

     

    The EF-S 60mm f/2.8 Macro lens will provide full-frame coverage with some very minor vignetting in the corners of the image on a full-frame EOS camera (digital or 35mm) if it is combined with either an EF 12 II or EF 25 II Extension Tube. The "II" is important, because the original EF extension tubes are not compatible with EF-S lenses.

     

    When the EF-S 60mm f/2.8 Macro is combined with an EF 12 II, the maximum working distance from the front of the lens to the subject is 363mm (14.3 inches) and the reproduction ratio is 1:5. The minimum working distance is 125mm (4.9 inches) and the reproduction ratio is approximately 1.3:1. With the EF 25 II, the maximum working distance from the front of the lens to the subject is 192mm (7.5 inches) and the reproduction ratio is approximately 1:2. The minimum working distance is 117mm (4.6 inches) and the reproduction ratio is approximately 1.6:1.

     

    You won't see the vignetting through the viewfinder on a 5D because of that camera's 96% coverage, but you can see it through a 1Ds or 1Ds Mark II viewfinder because of the 100% VF coverage on those models. In all 3 cases, the vignetting will show up in the extreme corners of the actual images, but it is so limited that it can easily be cropped out if desired.

     

    --------------------

    Chuck Westfall

    Director/Media & Customer Relationship

    Camera Division/Canon U.S.A., Inc.

  2. Interesting. But what happends with an aps sensor camera?

     

    Why use extesion ring? does It enable me to shoot smaller critters?

  3. Yes, you can use the lens on your 350D as well. The lens is made for use on the 350D, but not full frame cameras. What we find novel is that you can use it on a full frame camera if you use the extension tube.

     

    Cheers

    James

  4. Yes I got that!

     

    Infact I own a 350d and an ef-s60mm macro lens already.

     

    All know about all the downsides already but the thing I havent understood yet is if it is worth the cost of buying an extension ring?

     

    What can I win from using it with the 60mm?

     

    Larger magnification? Can I fill my frame with a subject smaller than 22mm (or whatever it was)

     

    Why am I asking theese questions, well I´m trying my best to find something else so that I do not have to buy the alluring 100mm :-)

  5. Yes I got that!

     

    Infact I own a 350d and an ef-s60mm macro lens already.

     

    All know about all the downsides already but the thing I havent understood yet is if it is worth the cost of buying an extension ring?

     

    What can I win from using it with the 60mm?

     

    Larger magnification? Can I fill my frame with a subject smaller than 22mm (or whatever it was)

     

    Why am I asking theese questions, well I´m trying my best to find something else so that I do not have to buy the alluring 100mm :-)

     

    I don't think an extension ring will help you much. It lets you get closer for higher magnification, but with the port in the way a 60mm at 1:1 is probably as close as you can get in practice and still be able to light the subject with your strobes.

     

    The 100mm gets you more working distance. You can get that by using a teleconverter. A 1.4x will give you a 84mm F/4 lens. You'll loss some autofocus performance and perhaps see some image quality difference in wide aperture settings.

    Edited by herbko
  6. As far as I am concerned this lens/extension has real potential in the reduced visibilty where I'm based. I found the 50mm Canon macro a bit limiting as it only goes to 1:2 and is slower than the 60 in its AF. It also extends whereas I don't think that the 60 does (Its IF I believe). The combination should reduce the working distance at very usef reproduction rations on FF and let me use a shorter port. All helpful stuff.

  7. I have a Sigma 50mm that has max magnification 1:1, but it does extend and with the relatively big Aquatica macro port, I find it very hard to light the subject at that magnification.

    Edited by herbko
  8. I don't think an extension ring will help you much. It lets you get closer for higher magnification, but with the port in the way a 60mm at 1:1 is probably as close as you can get in practice and still be able to light the subject with your strobes.

     

    Yes you are probably right, the small and compact 60mm leaves quite a bit of air between the port glass and the lens so trying to get much closer is probably not a good idea.

     

    The 100mm gets you more working distance. You can get that by using a teleconverter. A 1.4x will give you a 84mm F/4 lens. You'll loss some autofocus performance and perhaps see some image quality difference in wide aperture settings.

     

    Hmm, but will the teleconverters avaiable today fit an ef-s lens? I thought that they did not fit.

  9. Hmm, but will the teleconverters avaiable today fit an ef-s lens?  I thought that they did not fit.

     

    Good question. I don't know. Try asking the question on dpreview or robgalbraith boards.

  10. Hmm, but will the teleconverters avaiable today fit an ef-s lens?  I thought that they did not fit.

     

    As far as I can tell, EF-S lenses are not compatible with teleconverters made by Canon, Sigma, or Kenko.

     

    That is, unless you add an extension tube :)

     

    ~Matt Segal

  11. Yes you are probably right, the small and compact 60mm leaves quite a bit of air between the port glass and the lens so trying to get much closer is probably not a good idea.

     

    I have the 60mm and an Ikelite housing and there is almost no air between the port glass and the lens. Also, the 60mm is IF so does not change size as you focus, and its true focal length increases as you focus closer, extending the subject distance. I haven't experimented much with it yet but given that I already own it I think it's worth a try.

     

    Lanier

Ultralight Control Systems

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.