Skip to content

Lights, Strobes, and Lighting Technique / Archived topic

Just can't quite justify the cost...

Started by Draq ·

  • 26Posts
  • 26Replies

Read-only discussion

Just can't quite justify the cost...

26 posts
  1. We stopped making the LSD bag about 3 years ago. There was not enough interest for this item since most photographers make use of their existing carrying solutions, mainly the diving pockets, or they attach more ropes and clips to the Optical tube.

    I too wouldn’t bother with a bag.
    Orginally I was fitting my gadgets in large drysuit pockets, and I must say the LSD was nearly filling one cargo pocket.
    Then i had a few wetsuit dives, seeing me clipping that much accessories on D-rings:
    -1x LSD + 1 mask
    -2x Reductors + macro rings
    -Backscatter coloured filtered system (for another strobe)
    Very easy to grab gear and use my Retras in different ways during the dive. I would just clip/unclip, sometines leave an accessory on the seafloor for a while if i will be stationary (all are slightly negative).
    I like to keep macro rings and masks in pocket when i have one though.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  2. 7 hours ago, TimG said:

    Picking up Joss' point, do have a search around on WP for views on the YS-D3 before you buy......

    Most of the hate on S&S seems to be WP group think based on the D2's bad reputation. They just did a firmware update to fix the D3 triggering issues. 

    Never had a S&S strobe flood, but have had 2 different inons flood. their battery compartment o-ring design is garbage IMO. 

    Edited by Lewis88
  3. 1 hour ago, Lewis88 said:

    Most of the hate on S&S seems to be WP group think based on the D2's bad reputation. They just did a firmware update to fix the D3 triggering issues. 

    Never had a S&S strobe flood, but have had 2 different inons flood. their battery compartment o-ring design is garbage IMO. 

    It's not S&S hate, just experience - we see every post on here and try to help on a great many of them and we certainly see a lot more issues with S&S strobes.  No doubt a great many people use them successfully, but based on posts on here a lot more issues come up on S&S vs INON.    The D3 certainly seems to have some good design features but the jury is still out on reliability as they've only just been released. 

    My personal experience is with INON Z-240, my pair are 5 years old now and I have no issues with the battery cap and like that I can inspect the o-ring after installation.  The main thing with the INONs is using enough grease - if you do this they go on smoothly everytime.  Taking the cap off requires a little care but again they are fine and I'm still using my original o-rings.  I like the fact that the battery contact is separate from the cap.  I'm sure the S&S cap also works well and either strobe could flood from the normal causes for o-rings failing to seal.

  4. On 3/23/2021 at 5:38 PM, Lewis88 said:

    Most of the hate on S&S seems to be WP group think based on the D2's bad reputation. They just did a firmware update to fix the D3 triggering issues. 

    Never had a S&S strobe flood, but have had 2 different inons flood. their battery compartment o-ring design is garbage IMO. 

    Not to criticize your preferences; I think everyone should choose what works for them, but I have used Inon strobes for over 10 years.  D2000, Z240, Z330, S2000, and my son who also does underwater photography has been using Inons for about 7 years.  Neither of us has ever had a strobe flood.  Proper lube and using some reasonable caution when screwing down the cap seems to be the key.  A brief examination through the clear cap to confirm the O ring is not twisted is a good idea.  The O rings seem to last forever.  I change mine every few years out of caution, but then keep the old ones as spares.

    For those who are concerned, an additional O ring can be installed inside the cap, creating a double O ring situation.  Sorry you had problems, but I cannot agree with the garbage thing.  I have never has a S&S strobe, so have no knowledge other than what I read, and it appears that once S&S closed their China plant and moved production to Japan, things improved and I assume the D3 is made there as well.  It might take a while for their reputation to improve following the Chinese D2 issues.  Or maybe the D3 is crap.  I have no idea.

     

  5. I'm with Draq and Chris. Had Inon Z220s and Z240s between 2003-2020. No floods, no failures, no problems. I'd recommend them highly and have done often. 

    Now on Retras which I think are even better.

    Like Chris, I only know what the WPixers post about the S&Ss. 

    "You pay your money and you take your chances......."

  6. 9 hours ago, Draq said:

    For those who are concerned, an additional O ring can be installed inside the cap, creating a double O ring situation. 

    I do not advise to put the o-ring inside the cap.

    I own a pair of Z240 Type IV, and I had a battery compartment flood on a Z240 due to that adaptation.

    The top of the strobe, where the cap screws in is not properly flat and due to that it does not provide a proper seal. The extra space used by the oring place inside the cap, made that the regular oring did not got properly “activated” and that resulted in a battery compartment flood in the second dive I made.

    Fortunately only the batteries were damaged, I cleaned properly the battery compartment and it goes on like new. Still with me, being a reliable partner.

    I am not a big fan of S&S, but it’s system to close the battery compartment seams more reliable that the twisting cap in Inon.

    Besides that I had a problem with the push button for the pre-flash, the magnet got corroded. It has not easy to solve it, but finally i have found a way to go around it (I found a screw that fits the local and I placed a magnet under that screw). It when so well that I decided to do the same to the other strobe.

    The human interface in INON is not the most simple and forward. It takes a lot of time to read the manual and really understand the controls of the INONs. But after understanding, it becomes easy (like everything)

    That said, I like my INONs. For sure I won’t be buying new ones (Inon Z330 or Retras) while mines keep the good work. I do not change 1-2 dive trips for a pair of new strobes.

    If anybody wants to offer me a pair of Z330 or Retras to prove I am wrong, I will accept it and will came to this thread assuming I am wrong. ;) 

    Edited by pbalves
Aquatica

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.