Skip to content

Photography Gear and Technique / Archived topic

Wide angle lens

Started by l.babcock ·

  • 26Posts
  • 26Replies

Read-only discussion

Wide angle lens

26 posts
  1. Wide angle lens

    I would like to purchase a wide angle lens that would work both underwater and on land, I have had discussions privately with some members and I have narrowed it down to 2 lens the sigma 15 mm fish eye or the Nikon 10.5 mm fish eye ,if anyone has any other good choices let me know. Underwater I will be shooting reefs wrecks and fish, so I need a versatile lens. and I have used wide angle underwater before . I used to shoot nikonis 5 with ses & sea 15 mm lens, that was the only lens I used

     

     

    Thanks Larry

  2. What do you intend to shoot on land? If whatever it is has a lot of straight lines (indoors, for instance), these fisheyes will be problematic. In that case, I'd recommend the Nikon 12-24 or Sigma 12-24.

     

    Cheers

    James

  3. Wide angle lens

    I really didn’t want to purchase a $1000.00 lens give or take $100 or $200,

    Is the Nikon 12-24 is that much better than any other wide angle lens? , also does the lens focus up close.

     

    Larry

  4. Wide angle lens

    I've got the Sigma 12-24 and love it... works great both above and below... I think I paid around 750.00 or so... somewhere around there... less than the Nikon.

     

    - Sean

  5. Wide angle lens

    I called Ikelite, they do not make a dome port for the sigma 12-24.

     

    Larry

  6. You didn't mention that the lens had to fit in an Ikelite housing Larry. Have you already purchased the Ikelite?

     

    Cheers

    James

  7. The 12-24 is a great wide angle lens for topside use for sure, because it does not distort. However, I find the image quality of this lens unacceptable for it's cost. I'm more happy shooting my 18-70 kit lens if at all possible, and save the 12-24 for those instance where I just have to have that extra few degrees of width.

     

    Also, I don't like the 12-24 underwater that much either. There is a lot of noticable corner softness behind an Ike dome.

     

    I have not had the oppurtunity to shoot the 10.5, and play with the barrel distortion correction in Nikon Capture to comment on whether or not it would be a decent choice for topside use.

  8. Wide angle lens

    Yes , I have already bought the Ikelite Housing for my D70 , I am a Ikelite dealer, the price was right.

     

    Larry

  9. Wide angle lens

    more input would be very helpfull, I would like to make a decission by Friday

     

     

     

     

    Thanks

     

    Larry

  10. Wide angle lens

    Detonate, how come you didnt like the 12-24 underwater, and also what housing are you using with your camera.

  11. OK, how's this sound for a strategy:

     

    Get a 15mm Sigma fisheye for underwater use $350

     

    Get a Nikkor 24-85AFS for topside use ~ $250

     

    I just don't think you'll be happy with the 15mm fisheye as a topside lens.

     

    Cheers

    James

  12. Wide angle lens

    James, thanks for the reply, I have a 28-100 lens already, I would like to have a lens a little wider, I was thinking maybe going with the 15 mm for underwater, and the sigma 12-24 for topside, which would be a better WA lens for underwater, the 10.5 or 15mm since both of them are not any good topside.

     

    Larry

  13. I recommend the 15mm Sigma then. I don't recommend the 10.5 because simply put, it is not a wide angle lens - it's a fisheye lens when used on the D70. A fisheye lens is a specialty lens and it's rare to have a subject that can fill the frame.

     

    The 15mm is a fisheye lens when used on a FF camera, but on the D70, it's basically a wide angle lens with more barrel distortion than usual. It's just plain easier to use and you will get great results for a low price.

     

    Cheers

    James

  14. Re: Wide angle lens

    Detonate, how come you didnt like the 12-24 underwater, and also what housing are you using with your camera.
    I have an Ike housing.

     

    I find the performance of the lens between around 12-18mm to be too soft. And underwater you'll get considerable corner softness from the dome.

     

    The 18-24mm performance is excellent. Much better than the 18-24mm performance of the kit lens. I just feel that dropping almost a grand for this lens was a waste. I rarely use the lens, except for the fact that it is so expensive, I force myself to take it on at least 1 or 2 of my dives.

     

    -jim

  15. There are those who aren't so sure the 12-24 corner sharpness is any better behind an 8" dome while inspecting the test results after mounting an Aquatica dome on an Ikelite housing. Anyone care to claim spectacular results?

  16. I have the Nikkor 16 mm fisheye. I am very happy with it. The 17-80 kit lens has soft and distorted edges at the wide end.

     

    Hal

  17. Nikon 12-24 with Sea&Sea Compact Wide Port

    Is anybody using Sea&Sea Compact Wide Port with Nikon 12-24 lens? Is it better/worse then having a Dome Port?

     

    /riki

  18. I agree with Jim and Ike regarding the 12-24 corners... I have used this lens behind Ike's dome and Nexus dome with the same mediocre results. My 18-70 is much better. For 1000 bucks I was hoping for a lot more. My two favorite lenses currently are the 10.5 and 18-70 for the d70...

     

    M.

  19. James-

     

    do you have any images in your gallery that were taken with the 15mm Sigma?

     

    M.

  20. I agree with Jim and Ike regarding the 12-24 corners...  I have used this lens behind Ike's dome and Nexus dome with the same mediocre results.  My 18-70 is much better.  For 1000 bucks I was hoping for a lot more.  My two favorite lenses currently are the 10.5 and 18-70 for the d70...  

     

    M.

    Yeah, I don't think it's Ike's dome. I just think it's the nature of the lens.

     

    I just want to stress again that I don't think it's a terrible lens. I just think it's way over priced. I feel it is much more of a $600 lens at best.

     

    My favorite lens is still my 60mm, and once I wet my 105mm, it may become my favorite. I may start using my 18-70 again and giving it another shot. I think I need to replace my cheapy diopter though, as it may be what is causeing my lack luster results with that lens.

Reef Photo & Video

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.