New Monster Adapter LA-FE2.
Like a few here, my love of a digitally converted Nikonos RS13mm Fisheye on DSLR as a compact high quality and versatile optic has been part of my reason to delay entering the mirrorless world underwater. But time and technology march on. Not wishing to change to a Sony system for reasons partly related to topside shooting I have been thinking about options for deploying the RS13mm on my new Nauticam Z8 system. To work on Z series cameras, firstly an autofocus system is needed that either adapts to the screw-drive focus or replaces it. Secondly, there needs to be camera control of aperture and thirdly there needs to be a mechanical adapter that can connect from the lens to Nauticam’s N120 port system.
Isaac Szabo’s conversion of RS13s to work on Sony systems using a donor lens autofocus system and front element separated and mounted on a N100 housing port is reported to work very well for autofocus and aperture control on Sony systems. It is likely that the Megadap ETZ21 PRO adapter would allow Nikon Z cameras similarly to autofocus and control aperture well as the donor lens is listed as compatible with the Megadap adapter. But, as far as I know, Isaac hasn’t yet produced a front element/port that would work on Nauticam’s N120 port system with Z series Nikon cameras.
The recently announced Monster Adapter LA-FE2 is the first to contain both aperture and screw-drive autofocus motors and adapts Nikon F mount lenses to Sony cameras. I was therefore interested to explore the performance of this new adapter both on a Sony camera as designed, and stacked with the Megadap adapter on Nikon Zs and I acquired one of the first ones off the production line. First experience of use dry on the bench is not encouraging.
I used a Sony A6500 body that is listed as compatible with the Monster adapter and tried five Nikon F-mount lenses familiar to many underwater photographers.
· Firstly, the AF-S Micro Nikkor 60mm f2.8 G ED (internal focus motor) that is listed by Monster as compatible. This did not autofocus at all on the A6500. There was no aperture control and the camera displayed f1.0.
· Secondly the AF Nikkor 28-70mm f3.5-4.5D (screw-drive control) that is not on the current Monster compatibility list. This did not autofocus at all on the A6500. There was no aperture control and the camera displayed f1.0
· Thirdly, a Nikon F-mount Tokina 10-17mm f3.5-4.5 DX Fisheye (screw-drive control). This lens is not on Monster’s compatibility list. This did attempt to autofocus using both AFS and AFC, but only occasionally achieved correct focus, generally with close objects. Often the error message “Focus Cancel” was displayed by the A6500. There was no aperture control and the camera reported f1.0.
· Fourthly, a Nikkor AF-S Fisheye 8-15mm f3.5-4.5E ED (internal focus motor) that is listed by Monster as compatible. This autofocussed quite well most of the time and the aperture was controllable and reported correctly. However, there were occasions when it all seemed to go wrong and needed to be reset by switching off and back on, sometimes accompanied by remounting the lens.
· Finally, the digitally converted Nikkor 13mm RS Fisheye (screw-drive control). This lens did attempt to autofocus in both AFS and AFC. As expected, this water-contact lens was not able to focus on infinity in air but did achieve correct focus on very close objects perhaps half the time. It often moved in small increments and took some time to get to a correct focus point. Aperture control was inconsistent, sometimes working and sometimes not.
I then stacked the Monster adapter with the Megadap adapter so producing a unit similar to a Nikon FTZ F-mount to Z-mount adapter but containing a screw-drive autofocus motor. The unit did physically fit within the NA-Z8 housing although the non-removable tripod foot meant that the unit had to be mounted on the camera body before the housing camera saddle was attached. Using my Andrej Bellic made adapter that has bayonets for both for the N120 housing and the RS13mm lens I could mount the lens on my housing and engage with the camera body at the correct distance. However, this arrangement forced the Z8 into manual mode focussing (although there is no manual focus capability on the RS13mm) and there was no aperture control.
When removing the RS13mm from the housing I had a period of panic as the housing F-mount release button would not operate and the whole assembly appeared to be seized up. After reflection, I realised that the F-mount release lever on the Monster adapter is in a slightly different position compared with the Nikon FTZ adapter. I was able to get a finger in from the back of the opened housing to depress the lever and release the lens. Panic over.
So, at this moment, the Monster adapter is not looking like a good candidate to get the RS13mm underwater on Nikon systems. It is possible that for Sony, better results would have been achieved with one of the more recent full-frame camera bodies but I don’t have access to one to test. I note that Seacam have reported success with their adapted RS13s, the Monster adapter and unspecified Sony cameras – recent full frame ones I suspect. For Nikon I am not surprised that stacked adapters from different manufacturers didn’t work together electronically. It is possible that in future adapter firmware updates will improve compatibility, but I was particularly disappointed that the Sony A6500/Nikon 60mm that are listed by Monster as compatible did not in fact work. I am also concerned that with the lens/adapter combinations that did work there was inconsistency over time as to how well they worked.
From my perspective as a Z8 user, hopefully Isaac will come up with an option for adapting the RS13mm for Nikon mirrorless users soon! A screw-drive FTZ adapter from Nikon would be even more welcome but we have waited so many years for such a think from Nikon or a third party that I’m not holding my breath.