Skip to content

Photography Gear and Technique / Archived topic

D200 banding

Started by cor ·

  • 32Posts
  • 32Replies

Read-only discussion

D200 banding

32 posts
  1. whats the conclusion here?  should I wait a while for the next wave or am I safe to order now?

     

    There's still a long waiting list at most places so if you order today the chances are that you'll get a body not from the next wave but more likely the third or fourth wave of shipments at best. I'd feel confident ordering now. IMHO

     

    I should be getting mine in a couple of days(ordered in early Dec.). I'm curious to see if this "banding" phantom is an issue.

    Edited by climbrox
  2. The problem we have is of scale. If a problem appears with a new camera then the web hears from those who are interested in it quite vociferously. Determining just what percentage of the units have the problem is extremely difficult. At least one response here indicates that it is certainly not universal, so the question you have to ask is whether you are prepared to go in for a camera knowing that it might just have a problem which Nikon will have to sort out (if it does) and ensure that it is corrected. I remember when the Nikon EM came out - the percentage of defective cameras was said to be so small that Nikon simply replaced rather than repaired them. I do wonder if the same percentage would be heavily discussed on the web today and whether there would be a perception that the problem was far bigger than it actually was?!

     

    If I was in the market for a D200 I'd buy one and worry about its potential problems if and when they occurred.

  3. I think this is a really small issue affecting only certain photos. I think it is probably a design issue affecting all D200s though.

     

    Nikon will sort this out and fix it. Nikon fixed my backfocus on the D70. Worst case scenario as I see it will be that you'll have to send it in and part with it for 1-2 months. When they come up with a fix they will apply it to new cameras just as they did for the backfocus issue.

  4. I received my D200 yesterday. By shooting a light bulb at ISO200 I was able to duplicate the "banding" effect people are talking about. At ISO100 it did not appear. You have to zoom way in to see it. When I have more time I'll try to post examples but they don't really look any different than others that are already floating around. To my way of thinking this is a very minor issue that will only appear in a very specific situation. I don't see it causing a problem for me. I'll consider sending the body to back to Nikon if at some point it is an issue in my prints but I think that is unlikely. In the meantime I'm going to enjoy my new camera. It blows my old D100 away!

  5. David,

     

    Do you think the banding will occur around the sun in an underwater photo?

     

    Cheers

    James

  6. Obviously that would be a concern for underwater photographers. I just have no idea and it will be some time before I have this body in a housing and able to test that sort of shot. I'll try to take some land shots that include sunbursts.

  7. Here are the examples I mentioned.

    test1a.jpg

     

    and cropped and viewed at about 500%

     

    test1b.jpg

     

    I have not been able to duplicate this effect by shooting at the sun. I'll try to do some more experimenting and post some of those examples when I have more time.

    Edited by climbrox
  8. From what i see almost every owner off a D200 have this banding problem utleast in Sweden :-)

     

    Now this is not a big problem becuace you can still use the camera and if you see that this problem will be visible in your photos you still have time , under warranty to send the camera to nikon..

     

    But if you use to shoot in 200-400 isos and in the way that you ATRACT the banding.. whay sould you consider buying a nikon d200?

     

    As i say before 90% off the users will dont see it att all but low light photography, not just underwater but streetphotography & reportage will be a problem. Sportsfotogrphers say the nikon d200 is a great camera becauce she is very fast. Now imaging a stadium with brigh lights or a indor baskeball game .....

     

    I dont know guys. I love the nikon d200 but we must be objectiv and

    see the plus and contras not just becauce we are nikon lovers :-) we praise everything..

     

    From now the Nikno d200 is a kick ass camera for the price . Canon 5D play in another price division but what will be if Canon come out with a 20D replacemet? I say this becauce nikon still deliver the new cameras with the bandish problem..

     

    Lambis

  9. Sportsfotogrphers say the nikon d200 is a great camera becauce she is very fast.

     

    That's what I'm most impressed with. I'm supposed to do a shoot in a few weeks of a guy who is going to do snowboard/base jump of a large cliff here in northern Cali. I now have the ability to quickly shoot bursts of half a dozen frames with out filling the buffer. That's something could I never dream of doing with the D100. The color is also much better than the D100. Imges will require much less color correction.

    Edited by climbrox
  10. David you will get great shoots

    The D200 is like a kalasnikoff :-) That is one off the big advantages that d200 have over the new canon 5D

Keldan

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.