Wow, i have just stumbled onto this post & read the whole thing! Amazing opinions here.
So i thought i would add my view to keep the post alive!
Coming from australia, we definately do not have a tipping culture & to be honest, if i was asked for a tip i would be highly offended & just wouldn't give one & i would never be back either. I can't believe that these guys are expecting a tip for doing the job that they are paid for, which by the way i would already be paying them there wages as a CLIENT & not a guest! It is not my problem if you are not happy with your work conditions! Change them if you don't like them.
At the end of the day you are being paid for a customer service job & if you don't do your job well then you should be sacked, alternatively, if you do it well you should be rewarded by your employer. A tip is a tip & i would never supplement someones wages as seems to be the expectation here.
The service would have to be stellar & well above what is commonly expected in order to recieve a tip & even then it would be a tip, say $50-$100 for both my wife & I.
I think the best tip i could give someone is my return business & word of mouth. I have now been to fiji 4 times & dived with the same operator on every occasion as the service is exactly what it should be, smiles, a great crew who are friendly, good pricing & safety is paramount. These guys have never even mentioned the word tip & i have never offered one either. I like to think that our 4 trips there & the fact that i am now organising another trip next year with a group of friends is better than a tip for them. This way i know that everyone is getting something out of my money & the dive operators actually put money back into several villages which is a big plus for me.
So for all you guys who think you are owed a tip just because you are working, think again. If i like you i may come back & therefor keep you in a job longterm. Maybe you should appreciate what you have & not what you don't have.
Cheers Pete.