Usually they list it as a service charge but it's basically you're paying for the labor
This may be the case, but in many countries a government tax and "service" charge are added to the bill (up to 21%, for example in Indonesia), and I would be surprised if the individual employees actually see any of it. It's probable (Please correct me if I am wrong..it won't be the first time) that it's more of a Value Added Tax. Last year, whilst at an upmarket Lembeh resort, we were assured that service was included upon our orientation. (Frankly, I was surprised, as I had budgeted for tipping) Then, we were given an envelope upon checkout for tips, which seemed contradictory.
As a Canadian, contrary to popular belief, we do tip (not just our canoes), but probably not to the degree of Americans (but again, it varies like mad from individual to individual). I have just returned from Indonesia, and I again tipped,(but not individually, for the first time.) The guides, of course help me immensely! But, I thought what about the guy filling my Nitrox tank, or the lovely man that hauled my camera rig up the stairs to my room after the dive day, even though I tried to convince him not to? Or, (and this is why I don't like the guides getting the bulk of diver's tips, whilst leaving nothing else) what about the girl mopping the deck of the boat, cleaning the head or the equipment room after you're back enjoying a cocktail? I decided this time, I would give a tip to the hotel staff, kitchen staff and dive staff.
I really appreciated the tipping advice left at the last resort that I stayed (Black Sand, in Lembeh). They didn't push tipping, (although I wish that their wording had been a little more encouraging) They really thought that it should be up to the guest. The best part was that if you wanted to designate part of your tip to one person, so be it. I have never seen this, so I liked it a lot. It gave me the flexibility to reward good guiding, yet not ignore what was fine service from people I never even saw, like the staff that cleaned my room.
I am not a wealthy person; I am rich by the standards I see when I travel for diving. I abhor the "you should pay a certain percentage of the cost" attitude I have seen from many North American based liveaboards. I know that in some cases, the local staff do not ever see those tips; it ended up in the "western" liveaboard manager's or owner's pocket.
So, this thread will resurrect from time to time, because there are "no rules". Wouldn't it be nice if there were? (I'd rather there not be) Forgive me if I "spoil" it for someone that feels that by giving someone a month's salary's tip that may help them get access to health care that on their measly salary they could not afford will somehow "obligate them" on their holiday. $50 is the monthly salary for a dive guide in some parts of the world. I think we all need to put it into perspective. Instead of translating everything into the country's standards, i.e. based on their economy, try to think of it in perspective of your own existence. Maybe with a tip or two (and I'm not talking extravagant), you can help an employee send their child to school or nurse an ailing parent. When I unexpectedly ran into last year's guide at a different dive operation this year, I was given the warmest hug for my "month's salary" tip. It helped provide for his extended family the basics that we take for granted.
My 2 cents,
Marli