Sorry, but in each of my comments I made it clear I have NOTHING against tipping (I even tip myself)
Then your comment "But I'd rather have all the costs included initially when I book my trip, than arriving on location and being faced with an additional cost" confuses me. Because today tips or gratuities are not mandatory, and if you'd prefer not to have additional cost after reaching your destination I don't know what you could be speaking about....other than tips.
To make the comparison to other fields of industry: Oxfam is trying to bring awareness about fair trade, trying to convince people to buy coffee that has been grown by farmers who get a fair price for their product rather than buying coffee from a big compay who pay the local farmers peanuts. Ok, this "fair" coffee is a more expensive.
So if other industries can re-distribute profits, why not the dive industry...?
I think this is an invalid comparison, if for no other reason than we can tip the dive guide but we cannot tip the farmer. But to take it at face value: the profits haven't been redistributed, you have only paid more money for your coffee so the farmer could receive a better price for his crop. The company or buyer is certainly reaping the same profit or more (probably more because it is inconcievable to me that
all the extra money would go thru thier hands and onward to the farmer). In both this case and the case of tipping, nothing fundamental about the relationship between consumer and worker has changed. For the worker to receive better pay the consumer is paying more money. It is no different than a tip being paid to a dive guide in order for him to receive more money.
I think it's a scary evolution if tipping is to ensure that service levels stay high. Being European I'd go for a proper salary to keep the standard high,
For me, being a capitalist, I'd go for the best worker, the hardest worker, the most accomodating worker, having the opportunity to be remunerated according to his/her level of service. Forgive me...but I don't quite agree with unions or social-style economics

I realize that this **eat what you kill** philosophy isn't preferable to the European sensibility, but it does generate an incredibly malleable workforce (of course at the cost of a classed society).
And while I certainly wouldn't argue with your personal preference, my experience is that service in Europe, or better said certain parts of Europe, is not high. That's not a criticism but rather an example where the extra cost is not returned in service. In other words I think it is very important how the money is translated to the worker where the service or hospitality industry is concerned. We are going to pay the higher cost one way or the other, so my preference is to have some control over how and when it is applied.
Eventually the slaves broke free as well.....it's never too late to try and make a change...
Well, there is "free" and then there is "free", but that's a discussion for another time. In the end I don't disgaree with your sense of generosity but rather I disagree with what you believe will be the resulting level of service if regular tips are eliminated and instead only applied in special or "extra" circumstances.