That's called a fact.
Well, of course, they compare 100 % croped image of both.
If you want to take the real test with the mpixel in, your must compare a 60% image of the 5D2 with the 100% image of a D700 ![]()
anyway, please stop this ! ![]()
Read-only discussion
That's called a fact.
Well, of course, they compare 100 % croped image of both.
If you want to take the real test with the mpixel in, your must compare a 60% image of the 5D2 with the 100% image of a D700 ![]()
anyway, please stop this ! ![]()
Well, of course, they compare 100 % croped image of both. If you want to take the real test with the mpixel in, your must compare a 60% image of the 5D2 with the 100% image of a D700
There you go conflating resolution and noise again.
Those are two separate attributes and there is no question that the 5Dmk2 has a higher resolution sensor. Let's stick to noise, as that is the subject at hand.
Regarding noise measurement ... your summary description of the method employed to produce the data inaccurate. This describes the method employed: http://www.dxomark.com/index.php/eng/Techn.../Noise-protocol
Noise measurement is performed using a transmission target placed on top of a uniform light box. The transmission target, designed by DxO Labs, is made of a plate of thick black plastic with precision-drilled holes which are equipped with a range of neutral density filters designed to absorb the light identically for all wavelengths. The filters are made of pure optical glass with no structures that can be measured as noise. (While other image quality measurement solutions make use of printed targets, we believe such targets are inappropriate for noise measurement testing, as the intrinsic noise pattern of the print paper may be recorded by the tested camera and then confused with the camera’s own noise pattern.) Filters of close density are placed on neighboring positions to limit reciprocal illumination of the patches. The light box (placed behind the target) is composed of two fluorescent daylight spectrum tubes with a diffusing sheet on top, achieving a perfect uniformity on each filter. The luminance is about 1500cd/m2. We use filters having different light absorption levels ranging from 0% to 99.99%, so as to test over a dynamic range of 4 density steps (= 13.3 f-stops—a dynamic range much greater than today’s digital cameras). For comparison, a printed target dynamic is typically 2 density steps (6.65 f-stops), which is inadequate to simulate high-dynamic-range or backlit scenes. Each uniform zone on the chart (a “patch”) is measured for luminance (cd/m2) with a certified luminance-meter; then all the values are input into DxO Analyzer software. Once the target is measured and the DxO Analyzer software is calibrated, the selected camera shoots an image of the noise target at different ISO settings, and the noise for each color channel of the target image (R, Gr, Gb, B) is then measured. The mean gray level and noise values are computed for each patch and for all images shot at different ISO settings. These numerical values are interpolated for all gray levels to calculate and plot SNR curves, from which DxO Analyzer extracts the SNR 18%, the dynamic range, and the tonal range.
anyway, please stop this !
Nope.
...
ok, then we were not speaking about the same thing.
what is important, in my opinion, is how much ISO can you go up to get, at the end, a good image.
for this goal, I don't think the D700 is any better. and I don't see why would anyone care about something else than this ?
then, of course, if you compare cells by cells, I admit the D700 is, but of course he is because of less resolution=easier technology.
The question was :
how high can you crank up the iso before you get too much noise...
to THAT, including everything around, I think both the 5D2 and the D700 can go pretty high and would be hard to compare by eye.
![]()
ok, then we were not speaking about the same thing.
Maybe it is a language thing and something has gotten lost in translation. Let me try again one last time:
The Canon 5D Mk2 is about one stop behind the Nikon D700 with respect to what is commonly referred to as "noise" at almost every level of sensitivity.
Talk all you want about other things ... this is just a fact as established by every test I have ever seen published.
I thought you liked tests ... no? Earlier you were asking for test data.
Maybe it is a language thing and something has gotten lost in translation.
yes it is.
The Canon 5D Mk2 is about one stop behind the Nikon D700 with respect to what is commonly referred to as "noise" at almost every level of sensitivity.
yes, 100% compared to 100%.
I thought you liked tests ... no? Earlier you were asking for test data.
Tests compare 100% crops to 100% crops. which is useless in any cases. a real test as intresting for photographer is to put togeter two photos of the same thing with same ISO : a crop 100% of the D700 and a crop 60% of the 5D2. then you really compare the final noise capacity of the two cameras. ![]()
anyway, we are talking about different things.
A runs faster than B.
but B have longer legs than A.
you are saying "B have longer legs than A", which is true, I'm saying that whats care is who run faster.
(of course, as looking to noise. the D700 have many other advantages comparing to the 5D2).
"Crops' and '100%' have nothing to do with this whatsoever. The concept is Signal to Noise. You can talk in circles all you want ... but you were wrong.
One little suggestion ... before you decide to become the 'forum police' and protect everyone from MY bad information, please educate yourself first.
Hi Everyone,
thought i'd add something else to the actual subject. I shoot a D300. At the very beginning i predominantly used ISO 800, sometimes 400 to get better shutter times. I found the noise visible at 800, and disturbing at anything more than that, except when shooting black and white.
These days i mostly shoot ISO 200 and try to use the flash properly for both wide angle and macro instead. My use of high ISO has dropped to almost zero. I want to try some natural light shots with Alex's filter at ISO 400, but that involves travelling to the tropics and will have to wait until October.
ISO 1000 and above...i don't go there with my camera.
Curious to hear other people's experiences.
Cheers,
Simon
I find the results with high ISO shots with my D300 vary dramatically whether your photo has lots of shadows, or it's fairly brightly exposed.
I use ISO 1000 photographing wildlife when I need to, quite often near dusk or dawn.
This shot is at ISO 1000

Terms of Use Privacy Policy Guidelines We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.