-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
One problem is that the entrance pupil of the 8-15 moves with both focal length and angle of view. So there is no "right" position. I plan a focus stacking series in the pool with different extensions once I find the time. That should answer some of the questions here.
-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
I measured the Howshot 140 again as accurately as possible, and also the entrance pupil of the 8–15 with and without TC (to within about 1 mm). The pupil depends not only on the focal length but also on the angle of view: towards the image edge it moves forward by about 3 mm. For the planner, I used the value at large angles, which matters for corner sharpness. All data are now in the planner. The image shows the two 140 mm domes at the same scale, aligned on their mount faces. The radius is identical within 0.5 mm (68.5 vs. 69 mm), but the Howshot’s sphere sits about 6 mm higher on its mount: its centre of curvature is practically on the mount face, the Nauticam’s 6 mm behind it. Most of the difference in ring length comes from the housings, though: the Aquatica’s port flange is 4.8 mm further forward, and the Sea&Sea adapter adds another 20 mm. On a Nauticam housing, the Howshot would need about 52 mm of extension, only 6 mm less than the Nauticam 140 (about 58 mm). Since I don't have a Nauticam housing, I cannot measure it directly. You can see all the measurements I use in the planner. Let me know if something looks odd.
-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
For the Nauticam 140 I used Interceptor121's data: R 69 mm, glass down to the mount face, apex 63 mm in front of it. The data from the picture were a little bit off. It is critical how the glass dome is mounted to the base plate and how close it is to a true hemisphere. For this dome pictures with more detail would help.
-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
The data for the Nauticam and Zen domes are in the planner. Uncertainty: about ±1 mm on heights and ±3 mm on the radius for the two big domes. For the planner, these errors are small: 3 mm in R moves the virtual image only by a few millimetres. The better the pictures, the smaller the error. You can always check the correct position of the entry pupil using the method suggested by Ocean Optics: https://www.youtube.com/@OceanOptics2025. This method works quite well, and you can compare it with the calculation from the dome planner.
-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
I added Nauticam N120 housings to the dome port planner. There are only two dome ports selectable: the Howshot 140 and the Sea&Sea 170AR. These can be converted to Nauticam mount by changing the lug ring. If you want more domes included, just send me pictures, including a ruler, like this one. The ruler should be lifted to the center of the port to allow for an accurate measurement of the port radius.
-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
Thank you. The Nauticam N120 values agree with yours within +/- 0.5mm. Once I have the data for your dome ports, I will update the planner.
-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
Sorry, Sea&Sea 170AR, not Sea&Sea 120.
-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
I am actually interested in adding Nauticam and Zen domes to the planner since these are popular and I could adapt them to my Aquatica housing (I have the Aquatica-Sea&Sea adapter, and there is also a very new Aquatica-Nauticam adapter). What I need: For the housing, it is just one number, the distance between the camera sensor and the housing flange. This is for Nauticam N120 66.5 + 16 = 82.5 mm, correct? This number should be the same for all cameras in N120 housings, so it also works for Sony, etc. For the dome, the best is to send me a picture: Dome without shade, side view, mount face visible. Shot from about 1–2 m away with a longer focal length, to keep perspective distortion small. Camera at the height of the dome’s axis, square to it. Ruler held vertically in the same plane as the dome’s axis, touching the dome, or flat against the mount face. Plain background and even light, so the glass edge is visible. With this picture, I can do calculations similar to those for the mini dome shown here. Just send it to my email address. The Zen 170 has a larger curvature than the Sea&Sea 120 and should work perfectly with the 17-28 or the newer Tamron 16-30. But even with my smaller Sea&Sea 170 I can focus right at the dome at 17 mm.
-
Dome ports for the Z8: some measurements and an interactive planner
When I moved from the D500 to the Z8, I had to sort out my wide-angle setup for full frame. Lenses: the 8–15 fisheye plus a Kenko 1.4× TC (the version that works on the Z8, see the Kenko TC thread), the Z 14–30 f/4, the Z 17–28 f/2.8 and the Z 20 f/1.8. None of them worked well with my old domes: an Aquatica 4" mini dome, an Aquatica 6" and an adapted Ikelite 8" that’s about 20 years old. There’s a lot of good info here and on sites like interceptor121, but I couldn’t find a systematic, physics-based look at dome ports. Most sharpness tests are done on flat charts or brick walls. That mixes up lens sharpness and field curvature, and above water it tells you little about what happens behind a dome. So I did my own tests. Because they focus close, the 8–15 and the 17–28 should be the best candidates for smaller domes, so I concentrated on those two. I measured: the field curvature of the 8–15 (with and without TC) and of the 17–28, using focus-shift series with the camera rotated around the entrance pupil on a nodal rail; the geometry of my domes, including the Howshot 140 (practically the same as the Nauticam 140, at about half the price) and the Sea&Sea 170AR on an adapter. Lots of pictures, but the results are interesting: Sharpness: focused properly, both lenses are very sharp corner to corner at f/5.6. Diffraction: from about f/11 on, diffraction limits the sharpness. That’s physics, so no lens will do noticeably better at f/11 and smaller apertures. The TC: compared at the same effective focal length, it costs no measurable sharpness at f/5.6. In the corners the 8–15 with TC is even slightly better, because the TC only uses the centre of the fisheye’s image. Field curvature: neither lens has a flat field. The fisheye’s sharp surface is about halfway between a plane and a sphere, and the 17–28’s is much flatter. Behind a dome that actually helps, because the dome’s virtual image of a flat wall curves the same way. All results, with tables and figures, are here: https://www.reefcolors.com/essays/equipment-wide-angle-photography/ Based on this I built an interactive dome port planner: https://www.reefcolors.com/essays/equipment-dome-port-planner/ You pick the dome, lens, extension rings, aperture, focal length and focus distance. It shows: how far the dome’s centre is from the lens’s entrance pupil, and the optimal extension; vignetting by the dome or the port; the closest focus and the depth of field; how much of a flat wall is sharp; lens data such as reproduction ratio and angle of view. Right now it covers Nikon Z bodies in Aquatica housings and the lenses and domes I have or could measure. I’m happy to add other housings, lenses and domes if someone can provide the data, mainly port and extension dimensions, so let me know. Please tell me if you find bugs or anything that looks odd. My first pool shots agree well with the planner. Next up is a proper underwater test, with focus-shift series from a tripod in front of a tiled wall. That should show the combined effect of dome and lens on field curvature, sharpness and chromatic aberration, and give clean data for the domes. Wolfram
-
HowShot dome ports
I’ve just received my Howshot 140 mm dome port from DiverVision. As Atus mentioned, the quality is excellent, with nothing to complain about. Delivery from Taiwan took less than two weeks, although the package spent about a week in Frankfurt waiting for customs clearance. DiverVision seems to be a reliable company. This was my second order, and both arrived without any problems. Their email response times, however, can be somewhat unpredictable. I’ll be using the 140 mm dome port on my Aquatica housing with an Aquatica-to-Sea&Sea adapter and the Nikon 8–15 mm, both with and without the 1.4× teleconverter. My initial tests look really good with the correct extension.
-
Advanced Trigger for Nikon / Nauticam - Turtle or UW-Technics?
Here are a few pictures to show how the Z8, i-Turtle, and HF-1 work together. The first three pictures were all taken at ISO 100 and 1/250 s, with apertures of f/22, f/11, and f/3.3. For the last one, I used TTL because in manual mode the picture would have been completely overexposed. I don’t see any artifacts in the images, so at least with this combination, 1/250 s seems to be usable with the Z8 without any synchronization problems. The fourth picture shows what HSS can do: f/11 at 1/5000 s. Pretty crazy — I’m not sure if anyone actually needs 1/5000 s underwater. I also tried 1/8000 s, but then I get strong banding, although the exposure is still correct. 1/6000 s seems to be the limit. The way HSS is implemented by Backscatter is a little different from Nikon. With the Nikon SB-5000, the transition between normal flash mode (manual or TTL) and HSS is seamless. You don’t really notice that anything has changed, and TTL continues to work in HSS. With the HF-1, you have to set the flash to HSS. Otherwise, it simply doesn’t trigger when the exposure time is shorter than 1/250 s. I actually think this is quite useful because if you forget to switch to HSS, you immediately know something is wrong when you get a black frame. In HSS mode, the HF-1 always fires at full power, so the exposure has to be controlled by the camera in manual mode. The downside is that the recycle time is quite long. Flash intensity is roughly inversely proportional to the shutter speed, so as you increase the shutter speed, there isn’t much light left. One comment about the rechargeable battery in the i-Turtle: I have the older Smart Plus 2 with micro-USB and the smaller battery. The Smart Plus 3 has USB-C and a larger, user-replaceable battery. Even with the smaller battery, I get more than enough capacity for a week of diving, and I’ve never run out of power. There’s a small LED that indicates when the battery is getting low, but if you charge it occasionally, you’ll probably never see it.
-
Advanced Trigger for Nikon / Nauticam - Turtle or UW-Technics?
I’m using an i-Turtle Smart 2 with a Z8 and HF-1 flashes, and the combination works very well for me. Once the software for the camera/flash combination is loaded, there’s basically nothing to set up. Just switch the trigger on. The camera shows the flash symbol and all the usual flash options are available. TTL works well, as do manual mode, rear-curtain sync, and HSS. The trigger solves two issues with my camera/flash combination: 1. Nikon specifies 1/200 s as the maximum flash sync speed for the Z8, with 1/250 s only available with selected flashes, such as the SB-5000. With the i-Turtle and HF-1, I can use 1/250 s without getting any banding, dark stripes, or other problems. I’ve compared shots at 1/250 and 1/200 s and can’t see any difference. 2. The HF-1 is pretty powerful even at its lowest power setting. This can be an issue for macro work if you want to shoot with a more open aperture rather than stopping down to something like f/22. In TTL, I get properly exposed images even with the aperture wide open. If there’s a problem, Balazs has always been quick to respond. I started with the original i-Turtle on a D7000, then used it with a D500, and now the Z8. Over the years, I needed one upgrade and one firmware update. Both were straightforward: send it in, get the updated version back, and the price was reasonable.
-
blue shark snorkelling - strobe or not?
You can get great pictures of blue sharks with and without strobes. I prefer to use strobes to get better-balanced pictures of the white bellies of the sharks. I did a couple of trips with Joe Romeiro in Rhode Island. Unfortunately, he doesn't offer these trips anymore. End of August/beginning of September, I booked two trips with "Blue Shark Snorkel" in Cornwall.
-
Prescription Masks
In Germany, there’s Optik Pingel in Düsseldorf. They’re a regular optician, but one of their specialties is prescription diving masks. They help you find a mask that fits and can add lenses matching your prescription, including varifocals. You can meet them at the Boot Exhibition in January (which is also in Düsseldorf). I got a mask with varifocal lenses, and the result is great! As you can see, the glasses, glued to the back side of the mask, are really big. I can read my camera screen and still see distant objects sharply underwater. I barely notice the progressive correction at all. The only drawback is the price: it’s very expensive.
-
Image Review with Nikon 8-15mm + 1.4tc vs WWL-C 24mm
Thank you for this test! Which Kenko TC are you using? I have both the Teleplus Pro DC and the HD Pro. The 8-15 on the Z8 works only with the Pro DC and on the D500 only with the HD Pro (see here in the Forum: "Kenko Teleconverter and Nikon camera bodies"). I wonder if there is an IQ difference between these TCs, but I cannot check on the same camera, and I meanwhile sold the D500.