I have been an amateur underwater photographer for a few years. I have a passion for travel and capturing my trips in the best way possible. So when I also started diving, I soon picked up a camera to capture that aspect as well. Started off with a TG5 and when I got comfortable with that, I got a Hugyfot housing for the Nikon D500 with the Tokina fisheye and 40mm macro.
I moved to mirrorless for above water and I am considering making this move for underwater in the future so I don't have to bring two bodies along. However, the Tokina 10-17 is rather unique and the only real alternative to it would be the Nauticam FCP-1. I am still holding off this decision for now due to the high cost involved.

Hello,

Welcome aboard!

Regarding the eternal fisheye dilemma among you photographers, you will find tons of content in the forum but I'll give you a small spoiler: teleconverter + Canon 8-15 fisheye zoom. For the details, I'll leave you to the search function.

Ciao

On 11/28/2025 at 5:28 PM, Davide DB said:

Hello,

Welcome aboard!

Regarding the eternal fisheye dilemma among you photographers, you will find tons of content in the forum but I'll give you a small spoiler: teleconverter + Canon 8-15 fisheye zoom. For the details, I'll leave you to the search function.

Ciao

Personally not a fan at all of the Canon (or Nikon) 8-15mm full frame fish eyes. They basically have a circular image at 8mm that I never ever touch, and then a normal wide fisheye at 15mm, that is similar to the 10mm result on the Tokina. I like the ability to zoom in on the Tokina and there is nothing on Full Frame that can do that, other than with the FCP-1 now

On 11/28/2025 at 10:19 AM, eikenhorst said:

I moved to mirrorless for above water and I am considering making this move for underwater in the future so I don't have to bring two bodies along. However, the Tokina 10-17 is rather unique and the only real alternative to it would be the Nauticam FCP-1. I am still holding off this decision for now due to the high cost involved.

I've gone the same route and have had the same debate with myself. I love the Tokina 10-17 which I use as my go-to wide-angle lens on a Nikon D500. I've thought about a Nikon Z8 or Z6III and the Nikkor 24-50 and Nauticam WWL-C, a combination which many folks say is very good. I'd love to have the in-viewfinder review that mirrorless offers especially for snoot-shoots. But then I think of the cost: new housing, wet lens etc etc and think,... naah.

13 hours ago, eikenhorst said:

Personally not a fan at all of the Canon (or Nikon) 8-15mm full frame fish eyes. They basically have a circular image at 8mm that I never ever touch, and then a normal wide fisheye at 15mm, that is similar to the 10mm result on the Tokina. I like the ability to zoom in on the Tokina and there is nothing on Full Frame that can do that, other than with the FCP-1 now

What I wad thinking of actually, is the combination of 8-15mm FE with a teleconverter 1.4x or 2.0x.

If you search on the forum it's a hot topic.

The first post I found: