I'm interested in photographing whales up close while snorkeling, and I'm trying to decide between two destinations: the Dominican Republic and French Polynesia.

From what I understand, snorkeling with whales in the Dominican Republic is generally easier due to calmer sea conditions. However, there can sometimes be quite a few people in the water at the same time (about 10)

French Polynesia, on the other hand, seems to offer a more authentic and intimate experience, with smaller groups. The downside is that sea conditions can be more challenging and may occasionally require some strenuous swimming.

I'm a certified scuba diver with around 100 dives under my belt, but I'm not a particularly strong or fit swimmer.

Has anyone experienced whale snorkeling in either of these destinations? I'd really appreciate hearing your thoughts, especially regarding sea conditions, the physical effort required, group sizes, and photography opportunities.

Thanks in advance!

I was last month in Moorea, the rule are very stric.

Not more than 6 person + guide... and mximum 2 or 3 boat

We was 2 group/boat of 6

you can also see that

Edited 1 hour ago1 hr by CaolIla

I must say the organisation in French Polynésia is really good

But it nature... nothing is sure... We made 3 half day trip before it was possible to go in the water an see the whale under water...

I have no words to describe this experience